Episode 10

full
Published on:

10th Nov 2026

Shifting meters, harmonic tension, and prog-rock storytelling: Fooling Yourself (The Angry Young Man) (Styx)

Styx’s “Fooling Yourself (The Angry Young Man)” is a prog-rock masterclass in dramatic arrangement, shifting time signatures, and theatrical storytelling. This week, we dig into the song’s movement between 6/8, 4/4, 7/8, and 5/4; its off-balance rhythmic feel; Dennis DeYoung’s keyboard spotlight; Tommy Shaw’s lead vocal; and the tension created by major/minor vocal harmonies over a pedal tone. Trist and Elaine also explore how acoustic guitar, synthesizers, stereo-panned backing vocals, and an unconventional rhythmic emphasis create a cinematic sonic field that supports the song’s possible band-internal lyrical subtext.

In the Mailbag, Elaine and Trist respond to an indie artist’s reflection on creating, sharing, and being heard in an oversaturated music world. They agree that artistic work has value even when it reaches only a small audience, while challenging the idea that quality alone guarantees discovery: musicians and other creators need to share their work, advocate for it, and define whether their goal is personal fulfillment, community, or a career. The discussion also unpacks how the meaning of “indie artist” has changed, why comparison can derail creativity, and how making music together remains worthwhile at every skill level.

Listen to the song

Other links

About us

Trist Curless is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, educator, and sound engineer. As a performer, Trist has toured worldwide as a co-founder of the pop-jazz vocal group m-pact and a 10 year member of the Grammy-award winning The Manhattan Transfer. In addition to these two vocal powerhouse groups, he’s also performed with Take 6, Bobby McFerrin, New York Voices, Vox Audio, Naturally 7, and The Swingle Singers. His latest venture, The LHR Project, is a new vocal group collective celebrating legendary jazz vocal group Lambert, Hendricks, and Ross.

As an audio engineer, Trist has toured nationally with several vocal groups and bands in a large variety of venues, working for Grammy award winners Pentatonix and Take 6, as well as prominent a cappella vocal groups Straight No Chaser, VoicePlay, and Accent.

Elaine Chao, M.Ed is a San Francisco Bay Area-based vocalist, multi-instrumentalist, vocal percussionist, and songwriter whose career spans a cappella, contemporary worship, and classical music. She has leveraged her training in classical and choral music over the course of her contemporary performance, including in orchestras for musical theatre and in sacred spaces. In addition to music, she also is a martial artist and published author. She currently leads a product management team at a major software company dedicated to creative expression. All statements in this podcast are her own and do not reflect the opinions of her employer.

Transcript
Speaker:

Elaine: Hey, Trist!

Speaker:

Elaine: What do we have this week?

Speaker:

Trist: Elaine.

Speaker:

Trist: This week we have a great prog rock band – they're kind of prog

Speaker:

Trist: rock band, rock and roll band from the 70s and 80s, Styx.

Speaker:

Trist: Do you know much about Styx?

Speaker:

Elaine: I've heard of them.

Speaker:

Elaine: I don't know very much about them.

Speaker:

Trist: Okay, they have some hits.

Speaker:

Trist: And as usual, here on The Musician's Loupe, I've chosen

Speaker:

Trist: not one of the bigger hits, but people might know this one,

Speaker:

Trist: called "Fooling Yourself."

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay, so before we get into this, can you remind our

Speaker:

Elaine: listeners how we should be listening to music as a part of

Speaker:

Elaine: The Musician's Loupe community?

Speaker:

Trist: Of course. Here at The Musician's Loupe, we just like

Speaker:

Trist: to encourage you to find yourself your best listening

Speaker:

Trist: situation that you can.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe that means grabbing those nice, expensive headphones you

Speaker:

Trist: don't use that frequently.

Speaker:

Trist: And give a listen to the music that way.

Speaker:

Trist: We do appreciate, no matter how you are joining us, but just an

Speaker:

Trist: opportunity to listen a little better if you can.

Speaker:

Elaine: So we're going to leave the links to the song in the show

Speaker:

Elaine: notes, and give it a listen.

Speaker:

Elaine: We will be right back.

Speaker:

Elaine: And we're back.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: I have zero idea where I want to

Speaker:

Elaine: start with this, but that was a

Speaker:

Elaine: lot.

Speaker:

Elaine: There was a lot going on in that song.

Speaker:

Trist: It's fairly lengthy and yeah,

Speaker:

Trist: there's lots of sections, aren't

Speaker:

Trist: there?

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. And it was all over the place.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm really interested in hearing

Speaker:

Elaine: why you chose this song in

Speaker:

Elaine: particular.

Speaker:

Trist: I've always liked this band, and just recently, I was able to

Speaker:

Trist: catch live in concert Styx and the band Chicago.

Speaker:

Trist: And this was a song of theirs

Speaker:

Trist: again, not one of the biggest

Speaker:

Trist: hits, but I always liked this

Speaker:

Trist: one.

Speaker:

Trist: And by golly, they opened with it made me so happy to hear it.

Speaker:

Trist: And they sounded great.

Speaker:

Trist: And I just wanted to share it here.

Speaker:

Elaine: So they opened with this song!

Speaker:

Elaine: I could totally understand that; it has a lot of drama to it.

Speaker:

Elaine: I feel like there is a lot going on just the very beginning.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then it shifts gears and then it shifts again, and then

Speaker:

Elaine: it shifts again.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then it ends on a very

Speaker:

Elaine: similar kind of vibe as it opens

Speaker:

Elaine: on.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm interested in what you are

Speaker:

Elaine: hearing and what catches your

Speaker:

Elaine: attention first.

Speaker:

Trist: Well, in general, the band

Speaker:

Trist: always had kind of a theatrical

Speaker:

Trist: bent.

Speaker:

Trist: Like they were almost like mini musicals, their albums.

Speaker:

Trist: Often would be thematic.

Speaker:

Trist: So you could hear this as this is a scene in a show.

Speaker:

Trist: I've always liked that about their tunes.

Speaker:

Trist: So the lead singer on this song is Tommy Shaw.

Speaker:

Trist: He was probably mostly known as the "other" singer.

Speaker:

Trist: the other lead vocalist, Dennis DeYoung is probably on the

Speaker:

Trist: bigger hits and the voice people probably know the most.

Speaker:

Trist: But both excellent lead vocals

Speaker:

Trist: and, yeah, I just like the

Speaker:

Trist: storytelling and all the

Speaker:

Trist: instrumental sections.

Speaker:

Trist: I think they're really fun.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think the first thing that

Speaker:

Elaine: struck me was really the time

Speaker:

Elaine: changes.

Speaker:

Elaine: Man, those time changes were all over the place.

Speaker:

Elaine: I definitely felt a little bit off rhythm for a couple of it,

Speaker:

Elaine: because it just changed so frequently that it threw me off.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that there's a part of me that when there's a song with

Speaker:

Elaine: a groove in it, I really start getting into the groove.

Speaker:

Elaine: And when it changes, it's like, oh, oh, where are we going?

Speaker:

Elaine: And especially when it's just one or two measures that's

Speaker:

Elaine: inserted in there.

Speaker:

Elaine: So

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: I went down the rabbit hole, of

Speaker:

Elaine: course, and I started figuring

Speaker:

Elaine: out where all these changes

Speaker:

Elaine: happened because I wanted to

Speaker:

Elaine: know, well, what changes are

Speaker:

Elaine: they?

Speaker:

Elaine: How many changes are there?

Speaker:

Elaine: And I came up with at least five.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I could be argued into six

Speaker:

Elaine: just thinking about, there's a

Speaker:

Elaine: 6/8 there.

Speaker:

Elaine: There's a lot of 4/4.

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: Then there's a section that is straight up in 7.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: It

Speaker:

Trist: The

Speaker:

Elaine: returns.

Speaker:

Trist: synthesizer solo, I

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah,

Speaker:

Trist: think.

Speaker:

Elaine: exactly.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then there are two measures in there, after it returns to 4,

Speaker:

Elaine: that's in 5!

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then it returns to 6.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it's like whoa wait wait wait wait wait wait.

Speaker:

Elaine: What are

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: we doing here?

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so, can you talk a little

Speaker:

Elaine: bit about these meter changes

Speaker:

Elaine: and what it does to a particular

Speaker:

Elaine: song when a song changes meters

Speaker:

Elaine: like this.

Speaker:

Trist: Well, generally, I feel like

Speaker:

Trist: when you're writing something

Speaker:

Trist: like this.

Speaker:

Trist: I suppose one could give themselves the exercise of "I'm

Speaker:

Trist: going to write a song that's in, 7/4 or 7/8 or 6/8."

Speaker:

Trist: You give yourself an idea of, I want to write in this feel or in

Speaker:

Trist: this time signature.

Speaker:

Trist: It can be a part of that.

Speaker:

Trist: I think when it's effective these time changes is when it

Speaker:

Trist: just happens because musically you were called to do that.

Speaker:

Trist: Any line of a song where there's a phrase extension or an extra

Speaker:

Trist: bar of two beats, not just because it would be tricky, but

Speaker:

Trist: because the phrase or the feeling I'm going for feels like

Speaker:

Trist: I should have two more bars or two more beats.

Speaker:

Trist: I feel like that with this.

Speaker:

Trist: It doesn't feel forced to me

Speaker:

Trist: like, oh, let's make sure that

Speaker:

Trist: this section does something

Speaker:

Trist: different, but maybe it just

Speaker:

Trist: needed to.

Speaker:

Trist: And so sometimes texture, timbre, sound, instrument can

Speaker:

Trist: change what the feeling is.

Speaker:

Trist: And sometimes the key, and sometimes the meter.

Speaker:

Trist: So I think it's an effective use

Speaker:

Trist: of the different feelings that

Speaker:

Trist: they desire, with it having a

Speaker:

Trist: reason, instead of just the

Speaker:

Trist: reason being I wanted to do it a

Speaker:

Trist: bunch different.

Speaker:

Trist: But the music was calling them to do those things.

Speaker:

Trist: So I think it carries that well.

Speaker:

Elaine: So what I was thinking about as

Speaker:

Elaine: I was listening to this was the

Speaker:

Elaine: sense of the meter telling a

Speaker:

Elaine: story.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I loved what you said at the very beginning about Styx being

Speaker:

Elaine: very much more theatrical.

Speaker:

Elaine: There are lots of moments in here.

Speaker:

Elaine: There was like the holding on to

Speaker:

Elaine: the five before getting into the

Speaker:

Elaine: 4/4 section.

Speaker:

Elaine: It was just like, oh, yeah, I'm just like hanging out here.

Speaker:

Elaine: We're waiting for something to happen.

Speaker:

Trist: Right.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I started getting the sense of – and I don't know whether it

Speaker:

Elaine: was because I was taking a look at the album cover as I was

Speaker:

Elaine: listening to this.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it has this overlay, almost this outline of a horse in it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I was thinking about the rhythm of galloping and the

Speaker:

Elaine: rhythm of trotting and then the sense of being off balance.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so if I think about a gallop or a canter, it really is like

Speaker:

Elaine: this almost 6/8 type of thing as you're moving along.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then a trot is a one and two

Speaker:

Elaine: and three and four and up and

Speaker:

Elaine: down motion, which I really

Speaker:

Elaine: heard in the bass because there

Speaker:

Elaine: was a lot of octaving as it

Speaker:

Elaine: went, like 1-8-1-8-1-8 or

Speaker:

Elaine: 1-5-1-5-1-5.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so as it's doing all of this trading from 6/8 to 4/4, one of

Speaker:

Elaine: the things that I really got and I was thinking through was what

Speaker:

Elaine: was the point of the 7/8 and what was the point of the 5/4?

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think for both of them, there is a sense of being

Speaker:

Elaine: slightly off balance.

Speaker:

Elaine: It throws a listener off balance when you're in 7 or when you're

Speaker:

Elaine: in 5, unless it's a jam.

Speaker:

Elaine: You think about Take 5, Dave

Speaker:

Elaine: Brubeck, where the entire thing

Speaker:

Elaine: is in 5 and it really starts to

Speaker:

Elaine: rock.

Speaker:

Elaine: You really start to feel that 5.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think other songs where we have 7s, like a 7/8 in there.

Speaker:

Elaine: If you get into the 7, the 7

Speaker:

Elaine: starts to feel normal after a

Speaker:

Elaine: while, but

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: when it's just thrown in there for a little section in there, I

Speaker:

Elaine: think the intent is really to throw someone off balance.

Speaker:

Elaine: so when I circled back to the

Speaker:

Elaine: context of, oh, here I am

Speaker:

Elaine: thinking about this theatrical

Speaker:

Elaine: piece.

Speaker:

Elaine: What is the purpose of throwing the listener off balance?

Speaker:

Elaine: And that actually led me to the

Speaker:

Elaine: lyrics and trying to figure out

Speaker:

Elaine: how does this fit in with the

Speaker:

Elaine: lyrics, and how does this fit in

Speaker:

Elaine: with the theatricality of this

Speaker:

Elaine: piece?

Speaker:

Trist: Just a note, too.

Speaker:

Trist: It's interesting that the 7 is

Speaker:

Trist: for the solo, which makes it,

Speaker:

Trist: just a little more intricate for

Speaker:

Trist: the soloist, which is actually

Speaker:

Trist: the aforementioned Dennis

Speaker:

Trist: DeYoung, who again, normally

Speaker:

Trist: sings lots of the leads for

Speaker:

Trist: them.

Speaker:

Trist: But he's actually the one that plays the solo on that.

Speaker:

Elaine: Hm!

Speaker:

Elaine: Does he play all of the keys?

Speaker:

Trist: Yes.

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh, okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I definitely saw this as a keys forward type of track, and

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm interested in hearing, is that something that Styx is just

Speaker:

Elaine: well known for, just being a keys forward kind of group?

Speaker:

Trist: Um not exclusively.

Speaker:

Trist: They feature it a bit though.

Speaker:

Trist: He was definitely a lead voice, but it's almost like, I'm not

Speaker:

Trist: going to be the lead voice on this, but I play a lot of keys.

Speaker:

Trist: You're going to hear those for sure.

Speaker:

Trist: I don't know if that was part of it on purpose.

Speaker:

Trist: I'd read and I'd always heard

Speaker:

Trist: this, but apparently Tommy Shaw

Speaker:

Trist: wrote this.

Speaker:

Trist: This is like their seventh album, so they're well into

Speaker:

Trist: their career, have had some hits, and apparently, it was

Speaker:

Trist: originally based on his perception of Dennis DeYoung.

Speaker:

Trist: Things starting to fracture, as these rock groups do.

Speaker:

Trist: And he was the angry young man,

Speaker:

Trist: always kind of depressed every

Speaker:

Trist: time they would have a setback,

Speaker:

Trist: even though they've got this

Speaker:

Trist: success, but just a

Speaker:

Trist: perfectionist that always wanted

Speaker:

Trist: everything.

Speaker:

Trist: So that's an interesting insight to the possible lyric as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's something definitely to think about.

Speaker:

Elaine: Going back, though, to the lyrics and a little bit of the

Speaker:

Elaine: theatricality, just binding these two topics together.

Speaker:

Elaine: It really is the vocals for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: There's a part of it that reminds me a bit of Queen in, I

Speaker:

Elaine: think just about the same era, some of the operatic pieces.

Speaker:

Elaine: I go

Speaker:

Trist: All

Speaker:

Elaine: back

Speaker:

Trist: the

Speaker:

Elaine: to

Speaker:

Trist: harmonies.

Speaker:

Elaine: Bohemian.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah,

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, I think it's also Bohemian Rhapsody.

Speaker:

Elaine: There is something a little bit melodramatic about it, and not

Speaker:

Elaine: just the harmonies, but about the texture of it and the

Speaker:

Elaine: texture of the vocals.

Speaker:

Trist: And how the song is sectioned out.

Speaker:

Elaine: Exactly. And I think that there

Speaker:

Elaine: is something about that that

Speaker:

Elaine: reminds me a lot of Bohemian

Speaker:

Elaine: Rhapsody from that perspective,

Speaker:

Elaine: although I would say that in

Speaker:

Elaine: this particular case, the

Speaker:

Elaine: harmonies were super interesting

Speaker:

Elaine: to me because as I started

Speaker:

Elaine: listening closer and closer to

Speaker:

Elaine: it, those harmonies were holding

Speaker:

Elaine: seconds.

Speaker:

Elaine: There was a lot of tension in the

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah,

Speaker:

Elaine: vocals.

Speaker:

Trist: They're cool.

Speaker:

Elaine: Tell me more about that.

Speaker:

Trist: I just really like them.

Speaker:

Trist: I like playing around with the

Speaker:

Trist: major minor discrepancies in

Speaker:

Trist: places.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe you don't expect them,

Speaker:

Trist: like at the top of those

Speaker:

Trist: choruses.

Speaker:

Trist: I think when I heard it again

Speaker:

Trist: live, having not heard it for so

Speaker:

Trist: long, I think the way that it's

Speaker:

Trist: mixed on the album, the version

Speaker:

Trist: I've always heard, I guess I

Speaker:

Trist: didn't recall those chords being

Speaker:

Trist: the same.

Speaker:

Trist: So as I'm listening, my ear expects to hear certain things

Speaker:

Trist: and there's places where I could hear whoever the part was making

Speaker:

Trist: some minor chords in places that my ear wasn't ready for them.

Speaker:

Trist: I was like, oh, are those those chords minor there?

Speaker:

Trist: I guess I didn't- and then

Speaker:

Trist: listen to the album right after

Speaker:

Trist: the show because I it was stuck

Speaker:

Trist: with me.

Speaker:

Trist: I was like, did I always hear

Speaker:

Trist: those wrong or did they change

Speaker:

Trist: them?

Speaker:

Trist: No, it's they did it just like the album.

Speaker:

Elaine: I loved how the vocals really

Speaker:

Elaine: pulled us into the minor, the

Speaker:

Elaine: major.

Speaker:

Elaine: There was a lot of movement in there and all of that over

Speaker:

Elaine: basically a pedal tone.

Speaker:

Elaine: I know that you and I have talked about pedal tones in

Speaker:

Elaine: recent episodes, and so that's something where I think about it

Speaker:

Elaine: and think about the role of the vocals really changing the chord

Speaker:

Elaine: and really changing the texture of the music because of the

Speaker:

Elaine: tension with the bass in there or the core pedal tone in there.

Speaker:

Elaine: So some of the other things that I was thinking about is the role

Speaker:

Elaine: of the different instruments.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I was thinking about how the acoustic guitar really sticks

Speaker:

Elaine: out here, especially given the textural difference between the

Speaker:

Elaine: acoustic guitar and the keys, which are very synthy, I guess,

Speaker:

Elaine: if I were to say something.

Speaker:

Elaine: Can you talk a little bit about that texture difference and how

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: it balances out?

Speaker:

Trist: That's probably another reason that I like it.

Speaker:

Trist: I'm a sucker for that.

Speaker:

Trist: And a nice acoustic guitar where

Speaker:

Trist: either you expect it to be

Speaker:

Trist: electric guitar, or just in a

Speaker:

Trist: texture where the other

Speaker:

Trist: instruments don't seem

Speaker:

Trist: complementary.

Speaker:

Trist: And yet the acoustic guitar sounds amazing.

Speaker:

Trist: I'm definitely a sucker for that.

Speaker:

Trist: I love it.

Speaker:

Trist: I like where the guitar sits in this song.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it's also mixed kind of high, I'd say.

Speaker:

Elaine: It has a very delicate sound to it compared to some of the other

Speaker:

Elaine: acoustics that I've heard where it has a rounder, warmer lower

Speaker:

Elaine: tone in the instrument.

Speaker:

Elaine: What are your thoughts about the

Speaker:

Elaine: ways that the instruments on

Speaker:

Elaine: this track fill out the sonic

Speaker:

Elaine: range?

Speaker:

Trist: I think that's what's super helpful is that acoustic guitar.

Speaker:

Trist: I think that the timbre of that is really nice.

Speaker:

Trist: It feels like it's more spacious.

Speaker:

Trist: Doesn't feel like it takes up as much space because you already

Speaker:

Trist: have like the keyboard sounds.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's something that I was also thinking about.

Speaker:

Elaine: And actually when it comes to the entire sonic mix, one of the

Speaker:

Elaine: things that really confused me, my first listen through was how

Speaker:

Elaine: pulled back the main vocal was.

Speaker:

Elaine: I almost couldn't hear or

Speaker:

Elaine: distinguish the words in that

Speaker:

Elaine: first listen.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I found it really interesting that after I had the

Speaker:

Elaine: lyrics in front of me, all of a sudden I was able to really

Speaker:

Elaine: distinguish the main vocals, and it almost seemed like the

Speaker:

Elaine: background vocals were mixed, a whole bunch more forward, and I

Speaker:

Elaine: couldn't tell whether it was that the lead vocal had a little

Speaker:

Elaine: bit more of the acoustic guitar in it, and that it was maybe a

Speaker:

Elaine: little bit more narrower band, as opposed to the background

Speaker:

Elaine: vocals, which seem to have a more full tone in it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Is that something that you heard?

Speaker:

Trist: I think that effect probably

Speaker:

Trist: comes from just the way that the

Speaker:

Trist: other vocals are mixed and kind

Speaker:

Trist: of where they're panned, where

Speaker:

Trist: they take up the space in the

Speaker:

Trist: sonic field.

Speaker:

Trist: When they come from both sides

Speaker:

Trist: instead of straight up the

Speaker:

Trist: middle, maybe it feels a little

Speaker:

Trist: bigger.

Speaker:

Trist: I feel like they kind of surround you more than the lead.

Speaker:

Trist: That's possible.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm really confused, though,

Speaker:

Elaine: because I did hear it a lot more

Speaker:

Elaine: clearly later in subsequent

Speaker:

Elaine: listens.

Speaker:

Elaine: Just that first listen, it seemed to get lost in the rest

Speaker:

Elaine: of the noise.

Speaker:

Elaine: But the second, third, fourth time through, I was able to

Speaker:

Elaine: understand the words.

Speaker:

Elaine: Even not looking at it.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I was really intrigued by

Speaker:

Elaine: what was happening in that sonic

Speaker:

Elaine: experience, and

Speaker:

Trist: Hm.

Speaker:

Elaine: I didn't know if that was just a

Speaker:

Elaine: trick or whether it is that

Speaker:

Elaine: center versus stereo type of

Speaker:

Elaine: thing.

Speaker:

Trist: It could be.

Speaker:

Trist: It could have to do with the other sounds that are

Speaker:

Trist: conflicting in the range.

Speaker:

Trist: That could be.

Speaker:

Elaine: Let's shift over to talking about the lyrics and wrapping it

Speaker:

Elaine: up back with the meter.

Speaker:

Elaine: What did you think of the lyrics?

Speaker:

Trist: I mean, it's pretty straightforward.

Speaker:

Trist: It's like, wow, "you don't know how good you have it" message.

Speaker:

Trist: Again, right away, "You see the

Speaker:

Trist: world through your cynical

Speaker:

Trist: eyes."

Speaker:

Trist: First line.

Speaker:

Trist: "You're a troubled young man, I can tell."

Speaker:

Trist: Whatever you think has happened, "Got to get up."

Speaker:

Trist: It's a "dust yourself off and

Speaker:

Trist: start all over again" kind of a

Speaker:

Trist: song.

Speaker:

Trist: And then hearing that it might be about one of his own

Speaker:

Trist: bandmates, there's a lot more.

Speaker:

Trist: "Oh, okay.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Trist: I could see this when I can see

Speaker:

Trist: who it might be directed

Speaker:

Trist: toward."

Speaker:

Elaine: It's interesting you say that.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I guess looking at it through that lens, I might be

Speaker:

Elaine: able to see a slightly different interpretation than I had

Speaker:

Elaine: originally come to.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: As I took a look at the adjectives describing this

Speaker:

Elaine: person, because it really is a conversation between the person

Speaker:

Elaine: who's singing and someone else.

Speaker:

Elaine: One of them is, the lyrics say that this person is cynical,

Speaker:

Elaine: troubled, and angry.

Speaker:

Elaine: And at the same time the narrator has an opinion.

Speaker:

Elaine: So it's not just a description, like a storyteller type of song.

Speaker:

Elaine: And we've certainly seen those in The Musician's Loupe before.

Speaker:

Elaine: This is really something where

Speaker:

Elaine: the narrator has an opinion

Speaker:

Elaine: about this person and how this

Speaker:

Elaine: person is reacting and like

Speaker:

Elaine: whether or not it maps to

Speaker:

Elaine: reality.

Speaker:

Elaine: Now just thinking about it, one

Speaker:

Elaine: of the things that occurs to me

Speaker:

Elaine: is, you have this vocal going on

Speaker:

Elaine: and you almost have a response

Speaker:

Elaine: in the solos that are coming

Speaker:

Elaine: out.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I'm wondering if it is a

Speaker:

Elaine: bit of, I don't want to say

Speaker:

Elaine: accusation, but it is a message

Speaker:

Elaine: to the person who's playing the

Speaker:

Elaine: solo.

Speaker:

Elaine: And, it's a not so subtle message about this.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then the soloist basically

Speaker:

Elaine: responds with what, like a 7/8

Speaker:

Elaine: and then occasionally a 5/4 in

Speaker:

Elaine: there.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's almost interesting to me,

Speaker:

Elaine: the push and pull between the

Speaker:

Elaine: lead singer and the soloist in

Speaker:

Elaine: this case.

Speaker:

Trist: Again, knowing that tidbit about the possibility that it was

Speaker:

Trist: written about the band mate, it kind of falls true then.

Speaker:

Elaine: I want to finish up here with an

Speaker:

Elaine: observation, which is it starts

Speaker:

Elaine: with the 6/8, and almost a full

Speaker:

Elaine: minute of us falling into the

Speaker:

Elaine: 6/8.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then it ends in this 6/8.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then it ends up fading to black.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And in some ways, that 6/8 is everything is moving smoothly.

Speaker:

Elaine: Everything is going okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: And same thing with 4/4.

Speaker:

Elaine: 4/4 is a very common type of rhythm.

Speaker:

Elaine: Although I will point out as a sidebar here, one thing that I

Speaker:

Elaine: noticed about their 4/4 was that the emphasis on the 4/4 is not

Speaker:

Elaine: where we typically put it when we're playing rock.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's not like a 3/3/2 combination.

Speaker:

Elaine: It is a

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: 3/2/3 combination, which to me was like, oh, what's going on?

Speaker:

Elaine: Why do I feel so- I know

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: it's 4/4, but I'm feeling a little bit off.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I finally figured out it was because the emphasis was on

Speaker:

Elaine: something that I wouldn't normally put the emphasis on.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so as I take a look at this,

Speaker:

Elaine: and again, going back to the

Speaker:

Elaine: sevens, some of the emphases on

Speaker:

Elaine: the sixes, that it eventually

Speaker:

Elaine: comes back to this normal

Speaker:

Elaine: cadence.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I wonder if the texture that you were talking about going

Speaker:

Elaine: from six to four to seven to four to five and then back to

Speaker:

Elaine: six ends up creating the sense of, oh, we have this story

Speaker:

Elaine: within a narrative.

Speaker:

Elaine: There's some things in there that's kind of rocky and

Speaker:

Elaine: disruptive, but it ends up working out okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: It

Speaker:

Trist: Back

Speaker:

Elaine: ends

Speaker:

Trist: where

Speaker:

Elaine: up

Speaker:

Trist: we

Speaker:

Elaine: going

Speaker:

Trist: started.

Speaker:

Elaine: back to status quo.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, exactly.

Speaker:

Elaine: Back where you started, but also

Speaker:

Elaine: this sense of rightness in the

Speaker:

Elaine: world.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I do go back and say maybe the story is both in the

Speaker:

Elaine: music as well as in the lyrics.

Speaker:

Trist: That's an interesting observation.

Speaker:

Trist: I hadn't thought of it in that regard, but that totally makes

Speaker:

Trist: sense to me.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, anything else you want to say about the song?

Speaker:

Trist: I think that's it.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, let's move on to our next segment, which is.

Speaker:

Trist: The mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's right. The Mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: And if you're interested in

Speaker:

Elaine: getting a hold of us, you can

Speaker:

Elaine: email us at

Speaker:

Elaine: themusiciansloupe@gmail.com.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's L-O-U-P-E, or you can hit

Speaker:

Elaine: us up on Instagram or Threads

Speaker:

Elaine: @themusiciansloupe.

Speaker:

Trist: That would be the place that you

Speaker:

Trist: could tell us about your

Speaker:

Trist: favorite Styx song, or maybe

Speaker:

Trist: your favorite prog rock band, or

Speaker:

Trist: maybe your favorite time

Speaker:

Trist: signature or collection of them

Speaker:

Trist: or whatever.

Speaker:

Trist: Anything relative to the episode you're listening to now, or even

Speaker:

Trist: others, letting us know some songs you want to hear.

Speaker:

Trist: That's the place you do it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, somewhat entertaining that

Speaker:

Elaine: we are talking about prog rock

Speaker:

Elaine: today because today's post is

Speaker:

Elaine: from Threads from @dadrock74,

Speaker:

Elaine: also known as quote unquote Dad

Speaker:

Elaine: Rock.

Speaker:

Elaine: But his profile says that his name is Greg.

Speaker:

Elaine: This is from October of 2026.

Speaker:

Elaine: He writes, "Sometimes as an indie artist, it feels like that

Speaker:

Elaine: old joke if a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to

Speaker:

Elaine: hear it dot, dot, dot.

Speaker:

Elaine: But if you love creating and sharing and just feel joy from

Speaker:

Elaine: the process, then keep going.

Speaker:

Elaine: If nothing else, music and art heals the author and creates a

Speaker:

Elaine: more beautiful world.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I really believe that you will be seen / heard.

Speaker:

Elaine: Just be patient and don't give up."

Speaker:

Elaine: So my question around this is

Speaker:

Elaine: what about these statements do

Speaker:

Elaine: you agree with, because he makes

Speaker:

Elaine: like three or four different

Speaker:

Elaine: statements.

Speaker:

Elaine: And what do you disagree with, if anything?

Speaker:

Trist: Well, I think he's just using that old saying, if a songwriter

Speaker:

Trist: writes a song at home and no one hears it, does it matter?

Speaker:

Trist: Did it happen?

Speaker:

Trist: And he's implying that yes, of course, you don't have to create

Speaker:

Trist: art for others.

Speaker:

Trist: Art can be healing for the creator as well.

Speaker:

Trist: I think artistic creativity gives us a better world in all

Speaker:

Trist: the different art forms.

Speaker:

Trist: And there's glorifying and enjoying and extrapolating upon

Speaker:

Trist: art that has existed, such as we do here on this very podcast.

Speaker:

Trist: But there's also always a need for more.

Speaker:

Trist: I think artists sometimes get in the mindset of, oh, well, I just

Speaker:

Trist: heard this amazing songwriter or this amazing band, what would I

Speaker:

Trist: have to offer?

Speaker:

Trist: It's not as good as that.

Speaker:

Trist: Comparison is the thief of joy, right?

Speaker:

Trist: You're always comparing with these other things you've heard.

Speaker:

Trist: So what could I contribute?

Speaker:

Trist: And that's just misguided.

Speaker:

Trist: So much great art probably comes

Speaker:

Trist: from an artist who thought that

Speaker:

Trist: about their art at some point,

Speaker:

Trist: but for whatever reason, they

Speaker:

Trist: kept on going and contributed

Speaker:

Trist: what they did and maybe changed

Speaker:

Trist: some people, or at least gave

Speaker:

Trist: themselves some more joy,

Speaker:

Trist: putting some more beauty into

Speaker:

Trist: the world.

Speaker:

Elaine: I a hundred percent agree with you.

Speaker:

Elaine: Maybe this will be a short conversation, but the one thing

Speaker:

Elaine: that I was fixed on was, "and I really believe that you will be

Speaker:

Elaine: seen / heard."

Speaker:

Elaine: It's kind of a "if you build it,

Speaker:

Elaine: they will come" situation and

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm not sure I fully believe in

Speaker:

Elaine: that.

Speaker:

Elaine: Can you talk a little bit about that?

Speaker:

Trist: I do often say that basically the good stuff always comes out.

Speaker:

Trist: There are always exceptions, but

Speaker:

Trist: I feel like, man, if something

Speaker:

Trist: is really great, really has the

Speaker:

Trist: ability to reach people, even if

Speaker:

Trist: you're just doing it for a few

Speaker:

Trist: people, if it's that good, those

Speaker:

Trist: people won't stop talking about

Speaker:

Trist: it.

Speaker:

Trist: And they'll tell two friends and they'll tell two friends, etc..

Speaker:

Trist: There's always value in sharing.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that's the key thing there, though, is that there is

Speaker:

Elaine: this general commitment that you have to make to sharing your

Speaker:

Elaine: content or sharing the things that you create, whether it's in

Speaker:

Elaine: a small field or a large field.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think part of the reason I say

Speaker:

Elaine: that is that especially when

Speaker:

Elaine: things are so saturated right

Speaker:

Elaine: now.

Speaker:

Elaine: We are definitely inundated with content left, right and center.

Speaker:

Elaine: But if you don't post content at

Speaker:

Elaine: all, or if you don't share, or

Speaker:

Elaine: if you're not out there

Speaker:

Elaine: performing or sharing your art

Speaker:

Elaine: at all.

Speaker:

Elaine: I do agree that there is

Speaker:

Elaine: inherent value in that process

Speaker:

Elaine: of creation.

Speaker:

Elaine: It changes you.

Speaker:

Elaine: You have something out in the world now that you've invested

Speaker:

Elaine: part of your life into, whether it's an intellectual investment

Speaker:

Elaine: or whether it's an emotional investment, it's still there.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I think that the key for me

Speaker:

Elaine: is, we've talked a bit about

Speaker:

Elaine: marketing.

Speaker:

Elaine: We've talked a bit about what it takes to get your stuff heard.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's just one of those things

Speaker:

Elaine: where it's not like it's just

Speaker:

Elaine: going to come because you're

Speaker:

Elaine: good.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it kind of brings to mind

Speaker:

Elaine: some of the worst advice that

Speaker:

Elaine: I've ever gotten from my

Speaker:

Elaine: parents.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I love my parents, and they have given me a lot of great

Speaker:

Elaine: advice over the years.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I do remember them telling me when I was early on in my

Speaker:

Elaine: corporate career, that I should just keep my head down, do a

Speaker:

Elaine: good job, people will notice, and then I'll get promoted.

Speaker:

Elaine: And certainly they gave that

Speaker:

Elaine: advice to me out of love and

Speaker:

Elaine: goodwill because that's the way

Speaker:

Elaine: that things worked when they

Speaker:

Elaine: were younger.

Speaker:

Elaine: But in a world right now of personal brand and basically

Speaker:

Elaine: having to advocate for yourself and making sure that other

Speaker:

Elaine: people know what you want.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's one of those things that

Speaker:

Elaine: I didn't learn that lesson early

Speaker:

Elaine: on.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think that it's very similar in the music field in

Speaker:

Elaine: that if you are not actively sharing your work, then you're

Speaker:

Elaine: kind of missing out on other people listening to your work.

Speaker:

Elaine: I feel like there's something kind of idealistic about the,

Speaker:

Elaine: oh, if I just create the stuff and maybe share it with a couple

Speaker:

Elaine: of people, then a lot of people are going to hear my stuff.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think it's much more of an industry.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's much more of sometimes it's

Speaker:

Elaine: just luck of the draw, who

Speaker:

Elaine: happens to get fed the

Speaker:

Elaine: algorithm, or who seems to talk

Speaker:

Elaine: to who.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm really torn on this one.

Speaker:

Elaine: I do agree, though, that even if no one hears it except for your

Speaker:

Elaine: close friends, it's still worth it for you to do it.

Speaker:

Trist: This also all depends on the end goal, I guess.

Speaker:

Trist: Greg framed it as, "as an indie artist."

Speaker:

Trist: So as an indie artist, that means someone who's wanting to

Speaker:

Trist: do this, not just someone who writes songs occasionally for an

Speaker:

Trist: extra fun thing.

Speaker:

Trist: No, they're trying to be an artist and be heard.

Speaker:

Trist: So that's different in terms of just creating for yourself.

Speaker:

Trist: Have a great full other competent job and you're not

Speaker:

Trist: really trying to have a career again as an artist like it says.

Speaker:

Trist: I suppose that's probably the thing in terms of how much

Speaker:

Trist: you're trying to make it be commerce or product.

Speaker:

Elaine: Can you talk a little bit about the difference in your mind

Speaker:

Elaine: between a commercial artist and an indie artist?

Speaker:

Trist: That terminology has kind of blurred in the last 20 years.

Speaker:

Trist: An indie artist used to mean not

Speaker:

Trist: represented by a large music or

Speaker:

Trist: recording company that held all

Speaker:

Trist: of the keys to your ability to

Speaker:

Trist: be known widely for the most

Speaker:

Trist: part.

Speaker:

Trist: Now indie artist is like, oh,

Speaker:

Trist: it's so much better that I'm

Speaker:

Trist: doing this instead of having a

Speaker:

Trist: label.

Speaker:

Trist: And a commercial artist.

Speaker:

Trist: It's changed so much that those

Speaker:

Trist: terms don't really land for me

Speaker:

Trist: in a way that I can talk about

Speaker:

Trist: them as if they're different

Speaker:

Trist: things.

Speaker:

Trist: They can be both.

Speaker:

Trist: You can be an indie artist and have lots of success.

Speaker:

Trist: You can be an indie artist and ten people at the bar hear you

Speaker:

Trist: because that's all you play for.

Speaker:

Trist: The terms don't really quite mean what they used to.

Speaker:

Elaine: So as we wrap up this conversation, what would you

Speaker:

Elaine: like to tell the people who are out there creating, whether it

Speaker:

Elaine: is music or video games or any kind of creative endeavor that

Speaker:

Elaine: we have out there?

Speaker:

Elaine: What message would you give to

Speaker:

Elaine: them, especially if they're

Speaker:

Elaine: small?

Speaker:

Trist: absolutely.

Speaker:

Trist: Just what Greg said, just to keep doing it.

Speaker:

Trist: Keep going.

Speaker:

Trist: You can get a lot of it.

Speaker:

Trist: Even if you have to break it down to just doing it for your

Speaker:

Trist: enjoyment for a moment to remember that you love doing it.

Speaker:

Trist: It's something that you get something out of.

Speaker:

Trist: I honestly think most of the time the things that stop it are

Speaker:

Trist: just that comparison that, oh, there is a lot of the art that I

Speaker:

Trist: do out there in the world.

Speaker:

Trist: My contribution will not be important.

Speaker:

Trist: I think that probably happens quite frequently.

Speaker:

Trist: And not to give in to that voice

Speaker:

Trist: and just to create, just keep on

Speaker:

Trist: doing it.

Speaker:

Trist: That's really it.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm one hundred percent with you on this one.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that the types of joy that he's talking about and the

Speaker:

Elaine: creation process is something that I see in my own life.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it's something that I find a lot of satisfaction in, no

Speaker:

Elaine: matter whether it is something that I've created that's like a

Speaker:

Elaine: physical thing, like a sticker, or a podcast that we've released

Speaker:

Elaine: out into the world.

Speaker:

Elaine: Right.

Speaker:

Trist: Goodness

Speaker:

Elaine: Um,

Speaker:

Trist: knows there's enough of those, right?

Speaker:

Elaine: right.

Speaker:

Trist: It'd be very easy for us to be

Speaker:

Trist: like, why are we even doing

Speaker:

Trist: this?

Speaker:

Trist: There's so many podcasts.

Speaker:

Trist: No one wants to hear us.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well,

Speaker:

Trist: And yet

Speaker:

Elaine: I

Speaker:

Trist: you listen.

Speaker:

Elaine: Exactly.

Speaker:

Trist: Thank you folks.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I think there's also just

Speaker:

Elaine: the joy in making music and

Speaker:

Elaine: making music with one another in

Speaker:

Elaine: some cases.

Speaker:

Elaine: And maybe the one thing I would add is you don't necessarily

Speaker:

Elaine: have to be good at it in order to get the enjoyment out of it.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think there are a lot of

Speaker:

Elaine: people who might feel a little

Speaker:

Elaine: bit intimidated, especially if

Speaker:

Elaine: they're surrounded with really,

Speaker:

Elaine: really good people to say like,

Speaker:

Elaine: oh, I have nothing to bring to

Speaker:

Elaine: the table.

Speaker:

Elaine: But sometimes it's just that enthusiasm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And also there are people who are making music at all

Speaker:

Elaine: different levels together.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that togetherness is a huge thing.

Speaker:

Elaine: I

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: think about some of the cultures worldwide where community music

Speaker:

Elaine: is a big thing.

Speaker:

Elaine: You're just walking around

Speaker:

Elaine: singing and people join you and

Speaker:

Elaine: soon you have a bunch of people

Speaker:

Elaine: singing together.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that that is something that's incredibly beautiful.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I can guarantee you, not everyone who is singing as a

Speaker:

Elaine: part of that community experience is great.

Speaker:

Elaine: Not everyone's a professional musician, but that joy in

Speaker:

Elaine: singing and that community of singing is so important to the

Speaker:

Elaine: culture that it helps to form the culture around it.

Speaker:

Trist: Absolutely.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: Any last thoughts before we wrap up?

Speaker:

Trist: That's it.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, we're going to leave you here.

Speaker:

Elaine: But before we do, we have a big favor to ask of you.

Speaker:

Elaine: Please do share something of ours.

Speaker:

Elaine: We would love for you to share a playlist.

Speaker:

Elaine: We would love for you to share an episode with a friend.

Speaker:

Elaine: We know that you all have music

Speaker:

Elaine: loving friends, and we would

Speaker:

Elaine: love for you to tell them about

Speaker:

Elaine: us.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, that's the key.

Speaker:

Trist: I think the best thing to share really is those playlists and

Speaker:

Trist: use them for yourself, even if you've only heard an episode or

Speaker:

Trist: two from us, check out the playlist they make good travel

Speaker:

Trist: playlists because there's such a wide variety of songs.

Speaker:

Trist: And if something tickles your fancy and you want to know more

Speaker:

Trist: about it, bam!

Speaker:

Trist: There's a podcast that we did about it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And we have both season one and season two.

Speaker:

Elaine: If you want to listen to season

Speaker:

Elaine: one podcast, you can crack open

Speaker:

Elaine: one of those season one episodes

Speaker:

Elaine: and find the links right in the

Speaker:

Elaine: show notes.

Speaker:

Elaine: Otherwise season two links are right in the show notes attached

Speaker:

Elaine: to this podcast.

Speaker:

Trist: So share those things.

Speaker:

Trist: Get those things out there.

Speaker:

Trist: Let people hear these interesting songs.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, thank you for

Speaker:

Elaine: joining us and we'll see you

Speaker:

Elaine: next week.

Speaker:

Elaine: Leaving me hanging again.

Speaker:

Trist: Loud motorcycle.

Speaker:

Elaine: time for more tea.

Speaker:

Elaine: I was so confused by the song.

Listen for free

Show artwork for The Musician's Loupe

About the Podcast

The Musician's Loupe
Listen to music like a musician
A discussion about music and musicianship by Trist Curless (jazz singer, educator, sound engineer, and recording engineer, formerly of m-pact and The Manhattan Transfer) and Elaine Chao, M.Ed (multi-instrumentalist, vocalist, beatboxer, singer-songwriter, author, and former educator). Each week, we listen to a song together and discuss the music we love through the lens of decades in the music industry. Topics include analysis of songwriting, chord progression, instrumentation, recording technology, and arrangement.