Episode 11

full
Published on:

17th Nov 2026

R&B, protest songs, and unfulfilled prompse: Chains (Eric Benét)

Eric Benét’s “Chains” is a masterclass in how sophisticated R&B production can carry an urgent social message. In this episode of The Musician’s Loupe, Trist and Elaine unpack the track from Benét’s debut album, True to Myself, spotlighting its blues-inflected acoustic guitar, fat analog keyboard bass, restrained percussion, stop-time accents, and the gradual layering that makes each chorus feel larger. They also explore Benét’s vocal arranging and stereo mix, including self-layered background vocals, and the use of octave and unison used to sharpen key lyrics. Beyond the sonics, Trist and Elaine examine how “Chains” uses four character-driven vignettes to move from personal trauma and unrealized potential toward a collective call for freedom, solidarity, and engagement with systemic harm.

In the Mailbag, the conversation turns to why midlife can be a musician’s most focused and creatively productive era. Responding to a Threads post, Elaine and Trist consider the shift from early-career experimentation and skill-building to the more intentional use of accumulated craft, perspective, and limited time. They challenge narrow, youth-centered definitions of artistic success, arguing that “making it” can mean anything from completing a first original song to finding a sustainable public audience. The discussion frames aging not as a creative deadline, but as a source of refinement, wisdom, and increasingly meaningful art for musicians at every stage of life.

Listen to the song

Other links

About us

Trist Curless is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, educator, and sound engineer. As a performer, Trist has toured worldwide as a co-founder of the pop-jazz vocal group m-pact and a 10 year member of the Grammy-award winning The Manhattan Transfer. In addition to these two vocal powerhouse groups, he’s also performed with Take 6, Bobby McFerrin, New York Voices, Vox Audio, Naturally 7, and The Swingle Singers. His latest venture, The LHR Project, is a new vocal group collective celebrating legendary jazz vocal group Lambert, Hendricks, and Ross.

As an audio engineer, Trist has toured nationally with several vocal groups and bands in a large variety of venues, working for Grammy award winners Pentatonix and Take 6, as well as prominent a cappella vocal groups Straight No Chaser, VoicePlay, and Accent.

Elaine Chao, M.Ed is a San Francisco Bay Area-based vocalist, multi-instrumentalist, vocal percussionist, and songwriter whose career spans a cappella, contemporary worship, and classical music. She has leveraged her training in classical and choral music over the course of her contemporary performance, including in orchestras for musical theatre and in sacred spaces. In addition to music, she also is a martial artist and published author. She currently leads a product management team at a major software company dedicated to creative expression. All statements in this podcast are her own and do not reflect the opinions of her employer.

Transcript
Speaker:

Trist: All of my favorite documentaries

Speaker:

Trist: are when you start watching and

Speaker:

Trist: you think it's about one thing,

Speaker:

Trist: and then it's really about

Speaker:

Trist: something else.

Speaker:

Trist: So people

Speaker:

Elaine: Huh?

Speaker:

Trist: think they're getting a podcast about Eric Benét, but they're

Speaker:

Trist: really going to hear about

Speaker:

Elaine: About

Speaker:

Trist: incarceration

Speaker:

Elaine: mass incarceration.

Speaker:

Trist: rates of

Speaker:

Elaine: Hey, Trist, what do we have this week?

Speaker:

Trist: This week we have one of my favorite R&B singers, Eric

Speaker:

Trist: Benét, from his very first album, "True to Myself."

Speaker:

Trist: Today's song is called "Chains."

Speaker:

Elaine: Mm!

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, this is definitely something that I've heard before

Speaker:

Elaine: because you recommended the album to me some years

Speaker:

Trist: Oh,

Speaker:

Elaine: ago.

Speaker:

Trist: such a surprise.

Speaker:

Elaine: I know.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so as we get into this, can you remind our listeners how we

Speaker:

Elaine: should be listening to music as

Speaker:

Trist: Ooh,

Speaker:

Elaine: a part of The Musician's Loupe?

Speaker:

Trist: Yes, especially on this one.

Speaker:

Trist: Such a good sounding record.

Speaker:

Trist: We just like to encourage you to improve your listening situation

Speaker:

Trist: if you can.

Speaker:

Trist: We also are always thrilled to

Speaker:

Trist: have you, no matter how you are

Speaker:

Trist: joining us.

Speaker:

Trist: But if you have the ability to listen in a better manner this

Speaker:

Trist: time, do so.

Speaker:

Trist: I think you'll enjoy this.

Speaker:

Trist: Eric Benét tune with the nicer headphones, if you will, or in

Speaker:

Trist: your car without your kids.

Speaker:

Trist: And you can just crank it like you want.

Speaker:

Elaine: So we're going to go ahead and

Speaker:

Elaine: leave the links to the song in

Speaker:

Elaine: the show notes, and we will be

Speaker:

Elaine: right back.

Speaker:

Elaine: And we are back.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay. This is one of my favorite tracks from this album and I

Speaker:

Elaine: love, love, love the topic.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I'm interested out of all of

Speaker:

Elaine: the amazing tracks on this

Speaker:

Elaine: album, why did you choose this

Speaker:

Elaine: one?

Speaker:

Trist: I think a pretty clear, succinct

Speaker:

Trist: message in the just funky, great

Speaker:

Trist: music.

Speaker:

Trist: Especially as I've mentioned

Speaker:

Trist: before, even the episode before

Speaker:

Trist: this, I believe, I'm a sucker

Speaker:

Trist: for acoustic guitar mixed with

Speaker:

Trist: other instruments that you maybe

Speaker:

Trist: wouldn't expect.

Speaker:

Trist: I love in the intro, oh, this is kind of maybe a little

Speaker:

Trist: singer-songwritery thing with maybe just a little acoustic

Speaker:

Trist: guitar, and maybe some light drums will come in.

Speaker:

Trist: And this big fat analog keyboard bass that you might hear from

Speaker:

Trist: Parliament-Funkadelic or some 70s funk record comes right in

Speaker:

Trist: and wakes you up and lets you know this isn't going to be that

Speaker:

Trist: kind of party.

Speaker:

Trist: I just love everything about it, and I love his voice.

Speaker:

Trist: And him recording all of his own background vocals.

Speaker:

Trist: He just goes all out.

Speaker:

Trist: All the talents are on display on this one.

Speaker:

Trist: Love it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh, I didn't know that he had

Speaker:

Elaine: done all of the background

Speaker:

Elaine: vocals himself.

Speaker:

Trist: I'm pretty sure.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh, okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I agree with you on the

Speaker:

Elaine: acoustic one, although just

Speaker:

Elaine: thinking about it right now, it

Speaker:

Elaine: is a lot less of your

Speaker:

Elaine: traditional acoustic and more of

Speaker:

Elaine: what I would consider almost a

Speaker:

Elaine: blues?

Speaker:

Elaine: Kind of a blues acoustic where

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: it has a lot of hammers in it.

Speaker:

Elaine: You've got a lot of movement in it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I think that there is

Speaker:

Elaine: that heavy blues influence going

Speaker:

Elaine: on there.

Speaker:

Elaine: That bass, I didn't know it was a keyboard.

Speaker:

Elaine: I thought it was just a bass guitar with some really funky

Speaker:

Elaine: filters on it.

Speaker:

Trist: No.

Speaker:

Elaine: I just

Speaker:

Trist: Fat.

Speaker:

Elaine: wrote down like, yeah, really distorted, whompy thing with,

Speaker:

Elaine: with, you know, and I was like,

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: whompy was the only word that I could think of.

Speaker:

Trist: Fat analog keyboard for sure.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, it was interesting to me

Speaker:

Elaine: as well about where the drums

Speaker:

Elaine: fit into this song, because in

Speaker:

Elaine: that first section in the

Speaker:

Elaine: verses, we have the acoustic, we

Speaker:

Elaine: have this bass keyboard going in

Speaker:

Elaine: here.

Speaker:

Elaine: There is a little bit of percussion in there and it

Speaker:

Elaine: matches so well.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then of course, more percussion comes in later in the

Speaker:

Elaine: song, in the choruses.

Speaker:

Elaine: But that really pared back verse compared to the lushness of the

Speaker:

Elaine: chorus is something else that I heard in the song.

Speaker:

Trist: And of course, we at The Musician's Loupe are big fans of

Speaker:

Trist: a good stop time and really nice big, clean, quiet stop time on

Speaker:

Trist: this record happens a few times.

Speaker:

Trist: Love it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Can you talk a little bit about the vocals on this, especially

Speaker:

Elaine: in the chorus?

Speaker:

Elaine: I know that you said that he had sung all of it himself.

Speaker:

Elaine: What were you hearing as you were listening to that?

Speaker:

Trist: Oh, he just understands how to do that.

Speaker:

Trist: He understands how to voice the background parts and how to add

Speaker:

Trist: to the growth of the song, adding more parts and

Speaker:

Trist: contrapuntal things as they go.

Speaker:

Trist: He's got quite a range, can sing pretty high.

Speaker:

Trist: He knows his instrument and understands the role of those

Speaker:

Trist: background vocals really well.

Speaker:

Trist: And they just played to really good effect in this tune.

Speaker:

Elaine: One thing I also noticed about the vocals was how well they

Speaker:

Elaine: were mixed, in that I was listening to where the

Speaker:

Elaine: individual voices in that background were mixed and it was

Speaker:

Elaine: in the center, but it wasn't all in the center.

Speaker:

Elaine: You could definitely hear some things that were slightly panned

Speaker:

Elaine: left, some things that were slightly panned right.

Speaker:

Elaine: So you really got that stereo sound out of the mix.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: I also noticed that he pared

Speaker:

Elaine: back a lot near the end of the

Speaker:

Elaine: choruses on both of the

Speaker:

Elaine: choruses.

Speaker:

Elaine: So it was just an octave.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: his lower range I thought it was really interesting.

Speaker:

Elaine: I just kept on thinking Prince,

Speaker:

Elaine: like the lower part of Prince's

Speaker:

Elaine: range.

Speaker:

Elaine: Sometimes it gets a little bit more reedy, and

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: that's what I heard out of Eric Benét's voice in this particular

Speaker:

Elaine: track, which is that lower reediness that was panned left.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it was pulled back so much that you almost didn't hear it.

Speaker:

Elaine: It was more of a foundation of what

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: he was singing that was straight center.

Speaker:

Trist: Using that kind of octave doubling is a common technique

Speaker:

Trist: to reinforce, and like you said on those certain lines, "It's up

Speaker:

Trist: to no one else / You've got to free yourself" I think that's

Speaker:

Trist: one of the lines at least there.

Speaker:

Trist: Getting out of all of those parts, and coming down to those

Speaker:

Trist: unisons or octaves on the lyric you really want to get through.

Speaker:

Trist: This is one of those where there's this interesting, deep

Speaker:

Trist: story and message throughout, but it's very easy, first

Speaker:

Trist: listen, to not necessarily get a lot of it just because the music

Speaker:

Trist: is so good, right?

Speaker:

Trist: The music

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah.

Speaker:

Trist: is

Speaker:

Elaine: That's

Speaker:

Trist: so

Speaker:

Elaine: right.

Speaker:

Trist: interesting, like all the things we're talking about texturally,

Speaker:

Trist: and how great of a singer he is and the great vocals.

Speaker:

Trist: Second and third listen, it's

Speaker:

Trist: like, oh yeah, there's this

Speaker:

Trist: story.

Speaker:

Trist: Oh, wow.

Speaker:

Trist: Okay, now I'm getting- At least that's how I experienced- I

Speaker:

Trist: don't think I was instantly into the story as much as I just

Speaker:

Trist: loved the sound of the record.

Speaker:

Trist: So I think that's probably the biggest reason for that choice

Speaker:

Trist: there at the end of the chorus is emphasizing the message of

Speaker:

Trist: all of that.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's interesting you say that

Speaker:

Elaine: the orchestration, specifically

Speaker:

Elaine: unison and octaving, emphasizes

Speaker:

Elaine: that.

Speaker:

Elaine: I feel like, especially coming

Speaker:

Elaine: from an a cappella background,

Speaker:

Elaine: the times that we have heard

Speaker:

Elaine: arrangements go down to a

Speaker:

Elaine: unison.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's just so powerful just to hear all of those voices

Speaker:

Elaine: blending together in one note after you've been hearing

Speaker:

Elaine: harmony for such a long time.

Speaker:

Elaine: And actually, I remember the

Speaker:

Elaine: first time that I heard a group

Speaker:

Elaine: that was called 7, that's now

Speaker:

Elaine: Naturally 7.

Speaker:

Elaine: One of the things that someone

Speaker:

Elaine: observed the first time that I

Speaker:

Elaine: heard them was, wow, I have

Speaker:

Elaine: never heard a unison so pure in

Speaker:

Elaine: my life.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that was something that really struck me as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: They're an amazing gospel a cappella, but really

Speaker:

Elaine: contemporary kind of sound.

Speaker:

Elaine: And there's a lot going on in each one of their arrangements.

Speaker:

Elaine: And every once in a while they just pull out a of unison that

Speaker:

Elaine: is so pure that it just stops you in your tracks.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think it's very similar to

Speaker:

Elaine: what you were talking about

Speaker:

Elaine: here.

Speaker:

Elaine: So yeah, interesting for us to

Speaker:

Elaine: think about the role of unison

Speaker:

Elaine: or octaving in emphasizing that

Speaker:

Elaine: point.

Speaker:

Elaine: I just want to underscore what you just said.

Speaker:

Trist: It's a useful technique for emphasizing a lyric you want to

Speaker:

Trist: make sure everyone hears.

Speaker:

Elaine: So one other thing that I want

Speaker:

Elaine: to talk about is the concept of

Speaker:

Elaine: layering.

Speaker:

Elaine: You were talking about layering vocals, and one thing that I

Speaker:

Elaine: noticed was the subtle way in which the instruments layered.

Speaker:

Elaine: We were talking about the acoustic at the very top with

Speaker:

Elaine: this really fat bass keyboard that was going on, and the kick.

Speaker:

Elaine: In the chorus, we have the layer of the vocals, but we also have

Speaker:

Elaine: the addition of an electric guitar really panned left.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: and I was like, okay, cool.

Speaker:

Elaine: We have an electric guitar, but the second time we go back to

Speaker:

Elaine: the chorus, we have a second electric guitar, panned right.

Speaker:

Elaine: And they're playing slightly different things, like the one

Speaker:

Elaine: that is panned right is really covering those interstitial

Speaker:

Elaine: spots, what I would call like the pockets in the music.

Speaker:

Elaine: Whereas the electric guitar on

Speaker:

Elaine: the left hand side was more

Speaker:

Elaine: doubling the melody in some

Speaker:

Elaine: ways.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I just thought it was interesting, the interplay and

Speaker:

Elaine: the subtle addition of an instrument in a place where

Speaker:

Elaine: maybe you're not necessarily listening for it, but as I was

Speaker:

Elaine: listening more deeply to it, I was like, oh, that is there.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay, interesting.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it just adds to the sense of

Speaker:

Elaine: complexity and fullness that you

Speaker:

Elaine: have there.

Speaker:

Elaine: And certainly there were other places where I was like, oh,

Speaker:

Elaine: there's a keyboard in the mix?

Speaker:

Elaine: Was it in the first chorus?

Speaker:

Elaine: I can't tell.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Trist: Right.

Speaker:

Elaine: so that was just something I was listening for.

Speaker:

Trist: It's a pretty standard, but effective use of building the

Speaker:

Trist: song by adding different things panned either side.

Speaker:

Trist: We heard a lot of that in the first season in the Michael

Speaker:

Trist: Jackson record we listened to.

Speaker:

Trist: That whole album feels like

Speaker:

Trist: there's a guitarist just parked

Speaker:

Trist: in either ear, for almost the

Speaker:

Trist: whole record, playing these

Speaker:

Trist: different cool single line

Speaker:

Trist: rhythmic things.

Speaker:

Trist: So, not an uncommon technique for it to put those kind of

Speaker:

Trist: lines that way.

Speaker:

Trist: But yeah, not having everything from the front, it's just more

Speaker:

Trist: effective to build, even if you don't feel like it's building,

Speaker:

Trist: like getting louder, but just adding more to the sonic space

Speaker:

Trist: helps it feel like you're growing as the song builds.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, let's shift gears and talk

Speaker:

Elaine: about the thing that I think we

Speaker:

Elaine: all want to talk about which is

Speaker:

Elaine: lyrics

Speaker:

Trist: Ah!

Speaker:

Elaine: on this one.

Speaker:

Trist: you beat me to it.

Speaker:

Trist: I was just going to ask you to

Speaker:

Trist: give me your thoughts about

Speaker:

Trist: these lyrics.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, there's a lot to say about it, so I am interested in

Speaker:

Elaine: hearing from you.

Speaker:

Elaine: Where do you want me to start?

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe about the technique that

Speaker:

Trist: is used in terms of you've got

Speaker:

Trist: three versions of the same, it's

Speaker:

Trist: not the same story, but the same

Speaker:

Trist: message that's trying to be

Speaker:

Trist: delivered through three

Speaker:

Trist: different settings.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, I think we heard this in a previous episode that we did.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think it was Lasso the Moon?

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that that was something

Speaker:

Elaine: that was really interesting was

Speaker:

Elaine: the usage of vignettes in the

Speaker:

Elaine: storytelling.

Speaker:

Elaine: And actually I would claim that there are four of them.

Speaker:

Trist: Okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: There are four different

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: characters.

Speaker:

Trist: Right.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. So the first one is Tracy.

Speaker:

Elaine: The second one is Nathan.

Speaker:

Elaine: The third one is Rosie.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then the fourth one, the

Speaker:

Elaine: singer himself, which I think

Speaker:

Elaine: does seem to be a little bit

Speaker:

Elaine: autobiographical from that

Speaker:

Elaine: perspective.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so these four different

Speaker:

Elaine: characters that are in the song

Speaker:

Elaine: in some ways paint very, very

Speaker:

Elaine: subtle messages, I'd say, of

Speaker:

Elaine: brokenness.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so the three first stories,

Speaker:

Elaine: we're talking about some very

Speaker:

Elaine: serious things.

Speaker:

Elaine: We're talking about, molestation for the first one.

Speaker:

Elaine: For the second one, drug addiction.

Speaker:

Elaine: For the third one, it doesn't

Speaker:

Elaine: seem as serious, but it is a

Speaker:

Elaine: sense of despair that Rosie has

Speaker:

Elaine: in unfulfilled potential

Speaker:

Elaine: possibly, is where I would put

Speaker:

Elaine: it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And the fourth one is more of an observation.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think the fourth one really brings it all together.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I think when I think about

Speaker:

Elaine: the technique, it really is

Speaker:

Elaine: building empathy for a specific

Speaker:

Elaine: character.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I found it really

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting, especially in the

Speaker:

Elaine: first two, thinking about Tracy,

Speaker:

Elaine: she's described as a good girl,

Speaker:

Elaine: and then Nathan is described as

Speaker:

Elaine: a genius.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think about, where they end up and how they are impacted

Speaker:

Elaine: by the brokenness in the world, and how Eric Benét, like,

Speaker:

Elaine: describes it in his song.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it is a juxtaposition.

Speaker:

Elaine: Because Tracy is described as being slave to a secret.

Speaker:

Elaine: And again, with this whole

Speaker:

Elaine: context of chains, this concept

Speaker:

Elaine: of being enslaved by these

Speaker:

Elaine: weighty things that are weighing

Speaker:

Elaine: down on you and keeping you in

Speaker:

Elaine: place.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think the same thing with Nathan.

Speaker:

Elaine: What he is doing now as opposed to this genius that he's

Speaker:

Elaine: described as being.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then we have Rosie.

Speaker:

Elaine: She is described as having given up her dreams.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then just longing and watching as people are flying

Speaker:

Elaine: around as she's stuck in this dead end job.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I think about those three different examples.

Speaker:

Elaine: These are three almost exemplars of people who he might have

Speaker:

Elaine: known or who people in the community might know.

Speaker:

Elaine: And in the middle of these stories, there is this call and

Speaker:

Elaine: the chorus is, as you mentioned before, very simple.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's a very clear message.

Speaker:

Elaine: And the question is, is he

Speaker:

Elaine: singing this to them or is he

Speaker:

Elaine: singing this to a broader

Speaker:

Elaine: community or to the audience

Speaker:

Elaine: saying like, hey, here are

Speaker:

Elaine: examples.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it doesn't have to be the worst of the worst.

Speaker:

Elaine: It could look like a broken

Speaker:

Elaine: dream or an unfulfilled

Speaker:

Elaine: potential that someone like

Speaker:

Elaine: Rosie has.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then I think where he really brings it together, and where it

Speaker:

Elaine: really changes from just a description of brokenness and,

Speaker:

Elaine: "hey, you know, you can pull yourself up from the bootstraps"

Speaker:

Elaine: is in the bridge.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I know that we've talked before about the importance of a

Speaker:

Elaine: bridge a song and that often has the nugget of truth that the

Speaker:

Elaine: entire song is written around.

Speaker:

Elaine: I know we've talked about the bridge as being an inflection

Speaker:

Elaine: point, but this one is unusual in that I think that the

Speaker:

Elaine: inflection point actually happens in the fourth verse.

Speaker:

Elaine: So the bridge says, "Make a

Speaker:

Elaine: change, don't you be afraid, go

Speaker:

Elaine: on / Free your mind from the

Speaker:

Elaine: fear inside / and you won't be

Speaker:

Elaine: chained anymore."

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that is in some ways a reflection of the chorus.

Speaker:

Elaine: It seems like an extension of the chorus.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: But in the fourth verse where he talks about, "Look here, I'm a

Speaker:

Elaine: Black man / They say that I'm free / Seems like somebody still

Speaker:

Elaine: got chains on me."

Speaker:

Elaine: Which again brings it back to the concept of chains.

Speaker:

Elaine: The name of the song is

Speaker:

Elaine: "Chains," it's just like chains

Speaker:

Elaine: over and over and over again in

Speaker:

Elaine: the chorus.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, then he says, "Well, we

Speaker:

Elaine: got brothers killing brothers /

Speaker:

Elaine: Leaving young mothers to raise a

Speaker:

Elaine: family."

Speaker:

Elaine: And all of a sudden it goes from

Speaker:

Elaine: like this individual brokenness

Speaker:

Elaine: into a, hey, this is actually

Speaker:

Elaine: something that's happening in my

Speaker:

Elaine: community.

Speaker:

Elaine: We've got brothers killing brothers leaving young mothers.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think about when the song

Speaker:

Elaine: was written and when it was

Speaker:

Elaine: released in like the early mid

Speaker:

Elaine: 1990s and thinking about the

Speaker:

Elaine: Black community in the mid 1990s

Speaker:

Elaine: and the very deep concerns

Speaker:

Elaine: around mass incarceration at

Speaker:

Elaine: that time.

Speaker:

Elaine: Even now, but I think it was

Speaker:

Elaine: really becoming evident at that

Speaker:

Elaine: time.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then there's this line at the very end of verse four that

Speaker:

Elaine: says, "We gotta stay together to make it better."

Speaker:

Elaine: And that, I think, is the inflection point of the song.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that that is where it turns around from a lot of these

Speaker:

Elaine: individual stories where it's me, her, him, etc. into an "us."

Speaker:

Elaine: And then he turns it into a community call to action.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that reframes the first three characters because the

Speaker:

Elaine: first three characters are not necessarily just individuals.

Speaker:

Elaine: They're representations of what's happening in the

Speaker:

Elaine: community at large.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I see that last chorus

Speaker:

Elaine: then as a call to the community

Speaker:

Elaine: to don't stop breaking the

Speaker:

Elaine: chains.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like we have as a community, as a people, an opportunity to

Speaker:

Elaine: really change our world.

Speaker:

Trist: And he does actually change to "ourselves" when he sings,

Speaker:

Trist: "We've got to free ourselves."

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I think that that's something

Speaker:

Elaine: that is really interesting to

Speaker:

Elaine: me, just thinking about the call

Speaker:

Elaine: to action and also thinking

Speaker:

Elaine: about the role of music and

Speaker:

Elaine: activism.

Speaker:

Elaine: Certainly music has played a lot

Speaker:

Elaine: of roles in activism of various

Speaker:

Elaine: types, like we know protest

Speaker:

Elaine: songs.

Speaker:

Elaine: But this one is a protest song

Speaker:

Elaine: or a call to action or an

Speaker:

Elaine: activism song that doesn't sound

Speaker:

Elaine: like one.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so

Speaker:

Trist: Exactly.

Speaker:

Elaine: I was like, oh, okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm really interested in finding out more about what the

Speaker:

Elaine: community's reaction was to this particular song, especially as

Speaker:

Elaine: someone who doesn't belong to this community, as someone who

Speaker:

Elaine: hasn't been impacted by this type of systemic brokenness.

Speaker:

Trist: It is the case where it's much

Speaker:

Trist: easier and probably more

Speaker:

Trist: frequent to just take in and

Speaker:

Trist: enjoy the great musical moments,

Speaker:

Trist: technically, musically,

Speaker:

Trist: sonically.

Speaker:

Trist: It's a great sounding record, well recorded, sung well.

Speaker:

Trist: It's very easy to not get even a

Speaker:

Trist: fraction of what you've just

Speaker:

Trist: done there broken all of that

Speaker:

Trist: down.

Speaker:

Trist: Sometimes those messages have to be hidden that way.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I also think that it's our

Speaker:

Elaine: responsibility as listeners, as

Speaker:

Elaine: we're digging deeper into this,

Speaker:

Elaine: to really stop and sit with the

Speaker:

Elaine: topic that's raised and thinking

Speaker:

Elaine: about, even if it doesn't impact

Speaker:

Elaine: me directly, it impacts my

Speaker:

Elaine: neighbor, it impacts people

Speaker:

Elaine: around me.

Speaker:

Elaine: And thinking about, hey, what is my responsibility?

Speaker:

Elaine: What is my response to this?

Speaker:

Elaine: Is it to support?

Speaker:

Elaine: Is it to raise awareness?

Speaker:

Elaine: Is it to encourage?

Speaker:

Elaine: I don't know, but I think for us as listeners, as active

Speaker:

Elaine: listeners especially, to really engage with the topics that

Speaker:

Elaine: these types of protest songs surface and not just let it be

Speaker:

Elaine: an intellectual exercise.

Speaker:

Trist: It's cool to see how a song can bring up situations that might

Speaker:

Trist: not happen in your life and bring up issues with a community

Speaker:

Trist: that you may not be a part of.

Speaker:

Trist: It's an interesting way to hear about these stories without

Speaker:

Trist: reading an article or if you don't know somebody that's in a

Speaker:

Trist: particular group or demographic hearing songs from and about

Speaker:

Trist: them are a strong way of learning this information.

Speaker:

Trist: And like you said, digging further to see the background

Speaker:

Trist: and what's behind the lyric that the artist is sharing.

Speaker:

Elaine: A parallel of what you've just said is what some people have

Speaker:

Elaine: said about reading fiction and why it's so important to read

Speaker:

Elaine: fiction, especially fiction that's written by people who

Speaker:

Elaine: aren't like you, is that it begins to build the sense of

Speaker:

Elaine: compassion and empathy within you for another group of people.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think it's so important for us to learn about the

Speaker:

Elaine: experiences of others.

Speaker:

Elaine: And music is one of those ways

Speaker:

Elaine: that we can learn about this, to

Speaker:

Elaine: your point.

Speaker:

Elaine: So it's been interesting for me to think about the parallels

Speaker:

Elaine: between reading fiction and listening to music and really

Speaker:

Elaine: actively listening to music the way that we do.

Speaker:

Elaine: So any last thoughts before we move on?

Speaker:

Trist: Did I mention I love the

Speaker:

Trist: keyboard bass part at the very

Speaker:

Trist: beginning?

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, I did okay.

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Trist: I think we're good.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, I will say that this is definitely a banger of an album.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so give it a listen.

Speaker:

Elaine: I hope you enjoy the entire album as much as I do.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so with that, we're going to

Speaker:

Elaine: move on to our next segment,

Speaker:

Elaine: which is.

Speaker:

Trist: Mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's right, the Mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: And if you would like to get a

Speaker:

Elaine: hold of us, you can email us at

Speaker:

Elaine: themusiciansloupe@gmail.com.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's L O U P E. Or you can

Speaker:

Elaine: contact us via Threads or

Speaker:

Elaine: Instagram @themusiciansloupe.

Speaker:

Trist: Those are places you can just let us know what you think.

Speaker:

Trist: Let us know your thoughts.

Speaker:

Trist: Tell us that we should stop

Speaker:

Trist: podcasting forever, or give us

Speaker:

Trist: ideas for further songs to do,

Speaker:

Trist: or let us know something about

Speaker:

Trist: this episode.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe a factoid we got wrong, or extra tidbits you might know

Speaker:

Trist: about Eric Benét or this album.

Speaker:

Trist: That's the place to do it.

Speaker:

Elaine: This particular post is from Threads once again.

Speaker:

Elaine: It is from midlife.mystic from October 2026.

Speaker:

Elaine: And he[] writes, "Musicians who

Speaker:

Elaine: are in midlife and haven't quote

Speaker:

Elaine: unquote made it yet, dot dot

Speaker:

Elaine: dot, midlife is for doing your

Speaker:

Elaine: best work.

Speaker:

Elaine: Keep going."

Speaker:

Elaine: And so this little brief post really made me think about what

Speaker:

Elaine: was different for you after, let's say, 35 or so?

Speaker:

Elaine: I know that midlife is probably

Speaker:

Elaine: a little bit later than that,

Speaker:

Elaine: but what was different before

Speaker:

Elaine: and after 35 in the way that you

Speaker:

Elaine: made music or how you approached

Speaker:

Elaine: music?

Speaker:

Trist: I suppose to whatever degree

Speaker:

Trist: that you never really stop

Speaker:

Trist: learning.

Speaker:

Trist: There's that concept of as

Speaker:

Trist: musician, you're always

Speaker:

Trist: learning, you're always getting

Speaker:

Trist: better, you're always improving

Speaker:

Trist: your skills, you're always

Speaker:

Trist: growing.

Speaker:

Trist: But I do feel like there is a point.

Speaker:

Trist: As you've left school, whether

Speaker:

Trist: that's university or whatever,

Speaker:

Trist: if you decide you're going to be

Speaker:

Trist: a musician, I think you're doing

Speaker:

Trist: that more as you're younger, you

Speaker:

Trist: are still trying to create and

Speaker:

Trist: do your thing, but you're also

Speaker:

Trist: adding tools to the toolbox on

Speaker:

Trist: the way.

Speaker:

Trist: And there's a point where I think you're adding fewer

Speaker:

Trist: toolboxes and you're just able to more wisely select from those

Speaker:

Trist: which you have collected, if that makes sense.

Speaker:

Trist: So it's like, okay, I've kind of

Speaker:

Trist: gotten to the place where, sure,

Speaker:

Trist: I can't let these things go away

Speaker:

Trist: and atrophy and I should still

Speaker:

Trist: grow and be on top of getting

Speaker:

Trist: better.

Speaker:

Trist: But I feel like I've paid the

Speaker:

Trist: dues or again, like I say,

Speaker:

Trist: accumulated the tools for the

Speaker:

Trist: toolbox.

Speaker:

Trist: And now I can really get to the thing that I want to do.

Speaker:

Trist: I think maybe that's what he's addressing here.

Speaker:

Trist: And I think for me, that might be the case where at some point

Speaker:

Trist: it was like, oh, okay, I didn't feel like I was learning new

Speaker:

Trist: skills at the same time that I was making art.

Speaker:

Trist: I was utilizing the skills that I had learned.

Speaker:

Trist: I guess maybe even falsely at some point feeling like, well,

Speaker:

Trist: okay, I know all the things I need to know to do this.

Speaker:

Trist: Of course, you very soon realize, ooh, I have more things

Speaker:

Trist: to learn, but you still reach a bit of an arrival point.

Speaker:

Trist: Like, okay, I'm beyond the point where I'm needing to just, learn

Speaker:

Trist: all of my basics, and whatever discipline I'm working at.

Speaker:

Trist: I've been doing this a minute now.

Speaker:

Trist: Being in an a cappella group,

Speaker:

Trist: you had a first album, the

Speaker:

Trist: second album.

Speaker:

Trist: But then maybe when you're making the third one, okay, I'm

Speaker:

Trist: not learning how to make an album with these guys anymore.

Speaker:

Trist: I've done that a few times already.

Speaker:

Trist: We've learned what worked, what didn't work.

Speaker:

Trist: You feel like you're refining it a little bit more.

Speaker:

Trist: Again, using more of the

Speaker:

Trist: different tools that you've

Speaker:

Trist: collected.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think it's interesting to hear you say that.

Speaker:

Elaine: I will say that my teens and 20s was about exploration.

Speaker:

Elaine: You were saying like building new skills.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I just remember being

Speaker:

Elaine: unfocused and doing a whole lot

Speaker:

Elaine: of stuff.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like I wrote, I don't know, two

Speaker:

Elaine: or three musicals in my 20s and

Speaker:

Elaine: did a whole bunch of writing of

Speaker:

Elaine: songs for my a cappella group

Speaker:

Elaine: and then doing stuff at church

Speaker:

Elaine: and writing music left, right

Speaker:

Elaine: and center.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I'm not entirely sure that I had found my voice, so to speak,

Speaker:

Elaine: until my 30s.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think that there is something about maybe figuring

Speaker:

Elaine: out who you are.

Speaker:

Elaine: And some people I will say like

Speaker:

Elaine: know that extraordinarily early,

Speaker:

Elaine: but I was not one of those

Speaker:

Elaine: people.

Speaker:

Elaine: But to come to a place where I had a perspective on things.

Speaker:

Elaine: And also, I think there's something that happens when

Speaker:

Elaine: you're a little bit older, where you have to begin to start

Speaker:

Elaine: prioritizing and choosing what you do and choosing a little bit

Speaker:

Elaine: more carefully what you do.

Speaker:

Elaine: Especially as someone who is in the corporate world and does a

Speaker:

Elaine: lot of music, but also as an active martial artist, because I

Speaker:

Elaine: started martial arts in my 20s, was thinking about, hey, how do

Speaker:

Elaine: I balance all of these things?

Speaker:

Elaine: And what do I choose to do and when?

Speaker:

Elaine: And how do I get the highest impact thing out of myself and

Speaker:

Elaine: into the world?

Speaker:

Elaine: And why do I choose to do the thing that I do?

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I think that when I read the words, "This is your time to

Speaker:

Elaine: do your best work."

Speaker:

Elaine: In some ways, it's kind of

Speaker:

Elaine: you're doing your most focused

Speaker:

Elaine: work.

Speaker:

Elaine: You need to prioritize the types of things that you're doing that

Speaker:

Elaine: are just you and figuring out what that means.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that there is an element of that where I look at what my

Speaker:

Elaine: music looks like nowadays, and it is very different than what I

Speaker:

Elaine: did in my 20s.

Speaker:

Elaine: It is a lot more focused.

Speaker:

Elaine: The types of things that I do now, I have to be very careful

Speaker:

Elaine: with how I spend my time, because I just don't have as

Speaker:

Elaine: much energy as I used to.

Speaker:

Elaine: And certainly I have a lot more

Speaker:

Elaine: responsibilities now than I did

Speaker:

Elaine: before.

Speaker:

Elaine: Is there anything that I said that sparked something for you

Speaker:

Elaine: and like additional reflections.

Speaker:

Trist: Well, no, I agree with all of that.

Speaker:

Trist: But also I think he's kind of saying that with the post.

Speaker:

Trist: But also, he ends with "keep going."

Speaker:

Trist: So the post is a little bit of

Speaker:

Trist: what we've been addressing, but

Speaker:

Trist: it is also a hey, it's never too

Speaker:

Trist: late.

Speaker:

Trist: Don't worry about because you didn't start doing it when you

Speaker:

Trist: were younger or it wasn't your life's mission and now you're

Speaker:

Trist: just finding it.

Speaker:

Trist: That doesn't mean it can't happen for you now.

Speaker:

Trist: There are endless stories of musicians who didn't really find

Speaker:

Trist: their footing or come into the public consciousness or whatever

Speaker:

Trist: "made it" means to you.

Speaker:

Trist: He puts made it in quotes, which I like, because making it is

Speaker:

Trist: different for everybody.

Speaker:

Trist: "I completed my first original song."

Speaker:

Trist: That's making it for someone.

Speaker:

Trist: That's like, I never thought I would ever do that.

Speaker:

Trist: And others like, oh, my 1000th

Speaker:

Trist: song is finally something that a

Speaker:

Trist: publisher wanted.

Speaker:

Trist: That's making it.

Speaker:

Trist: So, that's different for everyone.

Speaker:

Trist: So I feel like it's probably a bit of the message that he's

Speaker:

Trist: saying with this post as well is, it's never too late.

Speaker:

Trist: And midlife is still a great time of exploration and you can

Speaker:

Trist: maybe become someone you didn't think you were.

Speaker:

Elaine: This brings to mind a story that I heard from someone who was

Speaker:

Elaine: going back to grad school in her 50s, and she was sharing a

Speaker:

Elaine: little bit about her rationale of going back to grad school.

Speaker:

Elaine: And she was saying that she was fully convinced that the most

Speaker:

Elaine: productive era in her life was going to be in her 80s.

Speaker:

Trist: Hm!

Speaker:

Elaine: And so she wanted to be prepared for that.

Speaker:

Elaine: So she was going to grad school in her 50s.

Speaker:

Trist: I love

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Trist: it.

Speaker:

Elaine: she's like, the second most productive time in my life is, I

Speaker:

Elaine: think, going to be in my 70s.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think that statement there really redefined aging for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that we are so afraid of getting old in our industry.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's double whammy because both

Speaker:

Elaine: in the music industry as well as

Speaker:

Elaine: in the tech industry, it's

Speaker:

Elaine: almost a death knell to be

Speaker:

Elaine: older.

Speaker:

Elaine: And to have that perspective on well, actually, you don't

Speaker:

Elaine: necessarily need to be young to do your best work.

Speaker:

Elaine: You can do your best work at any point in your life.

Speaker:

Elaine: And thinking about midlife as being another productive era

Speaker:

Elaine: where you can be maybe productive in a different way.

Speaker:

Elaine: But how many people do we know?

Speaker:

Elaine: Like we were talking about Harry Connick, Jr. recently and about

Speaker:

Elaine: just how prolific he's been.

Speaker:

Elaine: And sure, he started young, but

Speaker:

Elaine: he just kept on going, that a

Speaker:

Elaine: lot of his great work happened a

Speaker:

Elaine: lot later than when he was in

Speaker:

Elaine: his 20s.

Speaker:

Elaine: Think about how productive he

Speaker:

Elaine: was in his 30s and 40s and even

Speaker:

Elaine: to today.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I think about all of that almost as a judgment on how we

Speaker:

Elaine: perceive aging and how we perceive what it means to be

Speaker:

Elaine: relevant in our world today.

Speaker:

Trist: Mm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think that there's so much that people of all ages can

Speaker:

Elaine: bring into our world.

Speaker:

Elaine: Recently we've been talking

Speaker:

Elaine: about art and about the art that

Speaker:

Elaine: you bring into the world and the

Speaker:

Elaine: difference that you can make in

Speaker:

Elaine: a world.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think that the older I

Speaker:

Elaine: get, the more convinced I am

Speaker:

Elaine: that we all have a role to play

Speaker:

Elaine: in our broader community and

Speaker:

Elaine: that we shouldn't be denigrating

Speaker:

Elaine: our age because it is something

Speaker:

Elaine: that's valuable.

Speaker:

Elaine: We are in a very youth worshipping society nowadays.

Speaker:

Elaine: I don't know, it is something that I do need to think through

Speaker:

Elaine: because it is countercultural almost to say, hey, middle life

Speaker:

Elaine: is awesome and being older is awesome and we can be productive

Speaker:

Elaine: and really give back to our community and bring wisdom,

Speaker:

Elaine: bring music, bring joy at all ages of life.

Speaker:

Trist: And it's the wisdom and perspectives of someone who's

Speaker:

Trist: had more life experience putting those messages and feelings and

Speaker:

Trist: stories into their art that can make it more valuable.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. Well, anything else to say about this?

Speaker:

Trist: I think that's it.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: With that, we're going to wrap up the show.

Speaker:

Elaine: But before we do, we would love to remind you to please share

Speaker:

Elaine: something with a friend.

Speaker:

Elaine: We have playlists, we have episodes.

Speaker:

Elaine: If there's something that we've said, even in these Mailbag

Speaker:

Elaine: segments that have encouraged you or you think someone needs

Speaker:

Elaine: to hear, please do share that.

Speaker:

Trist: I like to share the playlists.

Speaker:

Trist: Check out these songs.

Speaker:

Trist: If any of these songs call to

Speaker:

Trist: you and you want to know more

Speaker:

Trist: about them, then check out the

Speaker:

Trist: pod and see what kind of a deep

Speaker:

Trist: dive we do or don't do with the

Speaker:

Trist: song.

Speaker:

Trist: Even if you share the playlist to just serve as a playlist,

Speaker:

Trist: they're great that way as well.

Speaker:

Trist: I personally like them for

Speaker:

Trist: travel just because there's so

Speaker:

Trist: much different kinds of music on

Speaker:

Trist: them.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, we're going to wrap up for this week.

Speaker:

Elaine: Thank you for joining us, and we will see you next time.

Speaker:

Trist: See you next time.

Speaker:

Elaine: You're only doing that because you're growly, huh?

Speaker:

Trist: I was trying to do something way

Speaker:

Trist: better than that, but I was too

Speaker:

Trist: growly.

Speaker:

Elaine: So like, listen to me.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm a baritone.

Speaker:

Elaine: Haha.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. Like F#0

Speaker:

Elaine: yeah, yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Trist: Was dumb.

Listen for free

Show artwork for The Musician's Loupe

About the Podcast

The Musician's Loupe
Listen to music like a musician
A discussion about music and musicianship by Trist Curless (jazz singer, educator, sound engineer, and recording engineer, formerly of m-pact and The Manhattan Transfer) and Elaine Chao, M.Ed (multi-instrumentalist, vocalist, beatboxer, singer-songwriter, author, and former educator). Each week, we listen to a song together and discuss the music we love through the lens of decades in the music industry. Topics include analysis of songwriting, chord progression, instrumentation, recording technology, and arrangement.