Episode 9

full
Published on:

3rd Nov 2026

Pentatonic melody, chromatic tension, and Carnaval: Um Canto de Afoxé Para o Bloco do Ilê (Caetano Veloso)

This week, we’re heading to Brazil as we cover Caetano Veloso’s Afro-Brazilian anthem “Um Canto de Afoxé Para o Bloco do Ilê,” often called “Ilê Aiyê.” Trist and Elaine unpack how percussion, call and response, a pentatonic melody, and carefully introduced chromatic tension create a full sound from deceptively spare materials. They also explore the song’s celebration of Salvador’s Ilê Aiyê Carnaval bloco, its affirmation of Afro-centric beauty and community, and the West African and candomblé influences woven into Brazilian music.

The Mailbag segment pulls back the curtain on the unglamorous reality of gigging and touring musicians: overnight drives, cheap coffee, hauling equipment, rushed soundchecks, early call times, and technical problems that must never show onstage. Drawing on stories from local performances, church services, event gigs, and touring, Elaine and Trist examine the preparation, resilience, and sacrifice behind a seemingly effortless performance.

Listen to the song

Other links

About us

Trist Curless is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, educator, and sound engineer. As a performer, Trist has toured worldwide as a co-founder of the pop-jazz vocal group m-pact and a 10 year member of the Grammy-award winning The Manhattan Transfer. In addition to these two vocal powerhouse groups, he’s also performed with Take 6, Bobby McFerrin, New York Voices, Vox Audio, Naturally 7, and The Swingle Singers. His latest venture, The LHR Project, is a new vocal group collective celebrating legendary jazz vocal group Lambert, Hendricks, and Ross.

As an audio engineer, Trist has toured nationally with several vocal groups and bands in a large variety of venues, working for Grammy award winners Pentatonix and Take 6, as well as prominent a cappella vocal groups Straight No Chaser, VoicePlay, and Accent.

Elaine Chao, M.Ed is a San Francisco Bay Area-based vocalist, multi-instrumentalist, vocal percussionist, and songwriter whose career spans a cappella, contemporary worship, and classical music. She has leveraged her training in classical and choral music over the course of her contemporary performance, including in orchestras for musical theatre and in sacred spaces. In addition to music, she also is a martial artist and published author. She currently leads a product management team at a major software company dedicated to creative expression. All statements in this podcast are her own and do not reflect the opinions of her employer.

Transcript
Speaker:

Elaine: Hey, Trist, what do we have this week?

Speaker:

Trist: This week we are switching it up

Speaker:

Trist: into something that's in

Speaker:

Trist: Portuguese, some Brazilian

Speaker:

Trist: music, a great Brazilian singer,

Speaker:

Trist: composer activist Caetano

Speaker:

Trist: Veloso.

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh, okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: This

Speaker:

Trist: And.

Speaker:

Elaine: is interesting for me because I do speak Brazilian Portuguese as

Speaker:

Elaine: my fourth language.

Speaker:

Trist: Oh.

Speaker:

Elaine: Uh, so somewhat familiar, but

Speaker:

Elaine: going back to my college days

Speaker:

Elaine: now.

Speaker:

Trist: Excellent. Okay, ladies and gentlemen.

Speaker:

Trist: This episode brought to you by Elaine Chao.

Speaker:

Trist: We'll see you guys at the end

Speaker:

Trist: after she does all the correct

Speaker:

Trist: pronunciations that I don't

Speaker:

Trist: have.

Speaker:

Trist: As a matter of fact, the full

Speaker:

Trist: length of the song title, I'm

Speaker:

Trist: not even going to try to say,

Speaker:

Trist: because generally the song title

Speaker:

Trist: is pretty commonly called "Ilê

Speaker:

Trist: Aiyê."

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay.

Speaker:

Trist: And that's kind of a nickname for it.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe you could give us the name of this full title that I've

Speaker:

Trist: shown you here.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay. So reading off the page here, this is "Um Canto de Afoxê

Speaker:

Elaine: Para o Bloco do Ilê."

Speaker:

Trist: Beautiful. Like I said "Ilê Aiyê."

Speaker:

Elaine: So before we get into listening

Speaker:

Elaine: to the song, can you remind us

Speaker:

Elaine: how we should be listening to

Speaker:

Elaine: music as a part of The

Speaker:

Elaine: Musician's Loupe?

Speaker:

Trist: We here at The Loupe like you to take a moment if you can, just

Speaker:

Trist: to remind you that you do own some nicer headphones that are

Speaker:

Trist: up in the closet that you keep away from the kids because

Speaker:

Trist: they're so expensive.

Speaker:

Trist: Pull those suckers out every once in a while and use them.

Speaker:

Trist: Get in your good listening room for a change.

Speaker:

Trist: We're thrilled to have you, no

Speaker:

Trist: matter where you're listening

Speaker:

Trist: from, your car, your jog, your

Speaker:

Trist: walk, whatever.

Speaker:

Trist: So, it's not a big deal either way.

Speaker:

Trist: We just like to encourage some better listening environments if

Speaker:

Trist: you have a moment to do so.

Speaker:

Elaine: So we're going to leave links to the songs in the show notes.

Speaker:

Elaine: Take a pause, listen to the song two or three times and we will

Speaker:

Elaine: be right back.

Speaker:

Elaine: And we're back.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay. So when you said Brazilian.

Speaker:

Elaine: I kind of expected bossa nova or

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: some of the other types of things, but this was definitely

Speaker:

Elaine: what I would consider like classic Brazilian music, not

Speaker:

Elaine: just like I said, bossa nova or samba or something like that.

Speaker:

Trist: Write a little more Carnaval sounding, like any of the musics

Speaker:

Trist: during that time, maybe.

Speaker:

Elaine: I would say that that is a good characterization.

Speaker:

Elaine: Can you tell me a little bit about why you chose the song?

Speaker:

Trist: as is sometimes, the not deep

Speaker:

Trist: theme here on The Musician's

Speaker:

Trist: Loupe is just I always liked

Speaker:

Trist: this one, a song I just wanted

Speaker:

Trist: to share and make sure people

Speaker:

Trist: knew about.

Speaker:

Trist: I do find fascinating, the fact that it's basically a cappella,

Speaker:

Trist: it's mostly vocals and just the drum sounds, percussion sounds,

Speaker:

Trist: yet it's not a cappella forward.

Speaker:

Trist: You don't leave it thinking that that piece of music was done a

Speaker:

Trist: cappella with some drums.

Speaker:

Trist: Describing it that way might lend your ear to think that it

Speaker:

Trist: sounds like something different from what it really is.

Speaker:

Trist: So I'm always fascinated by that

Speaker:

Trist: and how the background choir

Speaker:

Trist: group vocals really cover

Speaker:

Trist: everything.

Speaker:

Trist: They're really the full band.

Speaker:

Trist: Even though it's not always singing harmony, any harmony,

Speaker:

Trist: any chord changes we get from the music all come from the

Speaker:

Trist: group vocals, which

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah,

Speaker:

Trist: of course, I love.

Speaker:

Elaine: yeah, I love that as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it's interesting that you

Speaker:

Elaine: said Carnaval because as I was

Speaker:

Elaine: thinking about it, I was like,

Speaker:

Elaine: oh yeah, I could see this on a

Speaker:

Elaine: parade route.

Speaker:

Elaine: I could see this as a dance song.

Speaker:

Elaine: There's this medium tempo that it's keeping throughout.

Speaker:

Elaine: And also there is a sense of call and response, which I feel

Speaker:

Elaine: is a very African influence on our modern day music.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. Also, I liked the fact that there's not a lot of

Speaker:

Trist: different musical material throughout the piece.

Speaker:

Trist: We often talk about the form and structure.

Speaker:

Trist: The percussion rhythm stays

Speaker:

Trist: exactly the same the entire way

Speaker:

Trist: through.

Speaker:

Trist: There's a few different melodies

Speaker:

Trist: introduced, but like the lyrics

Speaker:

Trist: are a small set of lyrics that

Speaker:

Trist: are just repeated over and over

Speaker:

Trist: and over.

Speaker:

Trist: There are some slightly different additions of harmony

Speaker:

Trist: as it progresses.

Speaker:

Trist: Naturally, more different parts are added to the vocals in the

Speaker:

Trist: back, and there's kind of a vamp ish theme on the way out.

Speaker:

Trist: But it's not a lot of crazy differences in the form.

Speaker:

Trist: So if you analyze this musically

Speaker:

Trist: and was explaining it to

Speaker:

Trist: someone, it might not sound all

Speaker:

Trist: that appealing.

Speaker:

Trist: It might sound boring or uninteresting.

Speaker:

Trist: So that's another thing that's fascinating because there's kind

Speaker:

Trist: of not a lot there.

Speaker:

Trist: And yet it still feels full to me.

Speaker:

Trist: It feels like a full musical idea.

Speaker:

Trist: And not until I was starting to

Speaker:

Trist: break it down did I even think

Speaker:

Trist: about the fact that, oh, wow,

Speaker:

Trist: there's not really a lot here

Speaker:

Trist: because there's so much

Speaker:

Trist: repetition.

Speaker:

Trist: There's something about it that still feels complete.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's interesting that you say

Speaker:

Elaine: that it didn't strike you as

Speaker:

Elaine: being that interesting because

Speaker:

Elaine: of the repetition, whereas I

Speaker:

Elaine: heard it as more of a theme and

Speaker:

Elaine: variations.

Speaker:

Elaine: And the interesting part for me was the variation and the

Speaker:

Elaine: complexity that was introduced.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I don't think I heard that

Speaker:

Elaine: until maybe the second or third

Speaker:

Elaine: time through.

Speaker:

Elaine: The first time, I was like, okay, it's very repetitive.

Speaker:

Elaine: The second time I was trying to think through, oh, where does it

Speaker:

Elaine: vary based off of what I heard the first time?

Speaker:

Elaine: And it wasn't until I was sitting down and actually

Speaker:

Elaine: marking out, hey, this is what happens at this time code.

Speaker:

Elaine: This is what happens at this

Speaker:

Elaine: time code that I started to

Speaker:

Elaine: realize how different every

Speaker:

Elaine: section was.

Speaker:

Trist: Right.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that to me just proved that the changes were subtle, but

Speaker:

Elaine: they were very, very distinct.

Speaker:

Trist: And it's a good lesson in that

Speaker:

Trist: you don't need to do a lot to

Speaker:

Trist: have a growing effect, have the

Speaker:

Trist: music move.

Speaker:

Trist: Adding subtle, different things every time can still create this

Speaker:

Trist: motion like you're growing and the music's going somewhere.

Speaker:

Trist: Especially at the beginning, even just unison.

Speaker:

Trist: But again, the drums are so predominant that I don't leave

Speaker:

Trist: the listen feeling like it needed more or why aren't there

Speaker:

Trist: more instruments here?

Speaker:

Trist: It feels great.

Speaker:

Trist: And side note the child's voice

Speaker:

Trist: is a nine year old Moreno

Speaker:

Trist: Veloso, Caetano's son who, as an

Speaker:

Trist: adult, has a music career of his

Speaker:

Trist: own.

Speaker:

Elaine: HMM.

Speaker:

Elaine: Interesting.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay. I love that it stayed in the family.

Speaker:

Trist: Yes. Big time.

Speaker:

Elaine: Going back to what you were saying about the vocal variation

Speaker:

Elaine: or the arrangement variation, I was reading a little bit more

Speaker:

Elaine: about this because of course, I went down the rabbit hole.

Speaker:

Elaine: One of the things that I looked

Speaker:

Elaine: up was the word afoxé, because

Speaker:

Elaine: it

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: was not a word that I had studied learning Portuguese.

Speaker:

Elaine: And as I was taking a look at

Speaker:

Elaine: the article, one of the things

Speaker:

Elaine: that came out was this concept

Speaker:

Elaine: of the scale of five pitches,

Speaker:

Elaine: which we would call a pentatonic

Speaker:

Elaine: scale.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so what I did after then was

Speaker:

Elaine: just picked out, oh, what are

Speaker:

Elaine: the actual notes that are in the

Speaker:

Elaine: melody?

Speaker:

Elaine: And as I was doing that, I'm like, oh yeah, that's right.

Speaker:

Elaine: That is the scale of five pitches.

Speaker:

Elaine: And this is why it sounds so familiar, because this

Speaker:

Elaine: pentatonic scale is one that is used in a lot of different

Speaker:

Elaine: Brazilian pieces of music.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: was like, oh, that's why it sounds so familiar.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay, I got it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I was thinking about this pentatonic scale.

Speaker:

Elaine: And the interesting thing to me

Speaker:

Elaine: was the introduction of the

Speaker:

Elaine: chromatic.

Speaker:

Elaine: So there is a point in time, I

Speaker:

Elaine: think it's in the second verse

Speaker:

Elaine: or so where Caetano is like

Speaker:

Elaine: singing this chromatic while

Speaker:

Elaine: everyone else is singing this

Speaker:

Elaine: pentatonic scale.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it just introduced that amount of tension.

Speaker:

Elaine: It was very, very subtle.

Speaker:

Elaine: And at the same time, you know, it was the primary vocalist and

Speaker:

Elaine: so it stuck out because of that.

Speaker:

Elaine: But that chromatic repeated itself later.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I just found it interesting to think about, this

Speaker:

Elaine: very traditional pentatonic scale as a part of the melody

Speaker:

Elaine: and then what the voices were doing in the background that

Speaker:

Elaine: seemed so countercultural.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that to me was interesting.

Speaker:

Elaine: Do you know anything about that,

Speaker:

Elaine: or do you have any observations

Speaker:

Elaine: about that particular musical

Speaker:

Elaine: tidbit?

Speaker:

Trist: Mostly I just know the spot

Speaker:

Trist: you're talking about, and I love

Speaker:

Trist: that.

Speaker:

Trist: It seems like he's singing the main melody and the main lead.

Speaker:

Trist: And then just for that moment,

Speaker:

Trist: it's almost as if he wasn't

Speaker:

Trist: recording and he was just

Speaker:

Trist: thinking to himself, it'd be

Speaker:

Trist: cool if the bass part did this

Speaker:

Trist: right here.

Speaker:

Trist: But he happens to be recording

Speaker:

Trist: and he's on the microphone where

Speaker:

Trist: he's singing the lead vocal, and

Speaker:

Trist: he just happens to do it out

Speaker:

Trist: loud.

Speaker:

Trist: It's really cool.

Speaker:

Trist: It's just not something you would expect from that spot.

Speaker:

Trist: again, It's almost like you're

Speaker:

Trist: catching someone thinking, oh,

Speaker:

Trist: it'd be cool if this happened

Speaker:

Trist: and he's just singing along to

Speaker:

Trist: himself.

Speaker:

Trist: Who knows, maybe he was, and then they just thought it

Speaker:

Trist: sounded great and kept it.

Speaker:

Trist: I don't know.

Speaker:

Elaine: Well, a couple of cycles later you heard the choir break out

Speaker:

Elaine: into that same chromatic.

Speaker:

Trist: Right, right.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so that's why I thought it was intentional as, oh, the lead

Speaker:

Elaine: singer is introducing this.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: the arrangement actually breaks

Speaker:

Elaine: out into this about a minute

Speaker:

Elaine: later.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then it goes back into

Speaker:

Elaine: unison and then back into this

Speaker:

Elaine: choral thing and ends in this

Speaker:

Elaine: really interesting vocal

Speaker:

Elaine: tension.

Speaker:

Elaine: I couldn't tell whether it was a

Speaker:

Elaine: tritone, but I thought maybe it

Speaker:

Elaine: might be because it just sounded

Speaker:

Elaine: like one.

Speaker:

Trist: I just like that kind of

Speaker:

Trist: non-traditional phrasing, the

Speaker:

Trist: way that he sings that little

Speaker:

Trist: spot.

Speaker:

Trist: And then actually he stops singing the melody and the rest

Speaker:

Trist: of the singers are kind of taking it over for a minute, and

Speaker:

Trist: he jumps back in.

Speaker:

Elaine: So let's pivot and talk a little bit about the lyrics.

Speaker:

Elaine: I know that it's very repetitive.

Speaker:

Elaine: I did have to copy and paste, and then I did do my own

Speaker:

Elaine: translation at the same time as looking up another translation

Speaker:

Elaine: saying like, hey, what does this actually mean in English?

Speaker:

Elaine: Is there something in the

Speaker:

Elaine: translation of the lyrics that

Speaker:

Elaine: you saw?

Speaker:

Elaine: This is a foreign language to you and I know that you have

Speaker:

Elaine: sung in Portuguese before, but not necessarily studied it

Speaker:

Elaine: academically like I did.

Speaker:

Trist: Right. And actually, I have sung these exact lyrics in

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh!

Speaker:

Trist: Portuguese.

Speaker:

Trist: I performed this one before a long time ago.

Speaker:

Trist: Something that I didn't know

Speaker:

Trist: back when I did that is that the

Speaker:

Trist: Ilê Aiyê is kind of a tribute to

Speaker:

Trist: a band.

Speaker:

Trist: There was a band that was a revolutionary type musical

Speaker:

Trist: output in Brazil.

Speaker:

Trist: If I'm remembering this

Speaker:

Trist: correctly, there was a name of a

Speaker:

Trist: band that was important for

Speaker:

Trist: that.

Speaker:

Trist: I did not know that.

Speaker:

Trist: I only knew of the phrase from this song.

Speaker:

Trist: So it was cool to find that out.

Speaker:

Elaine: I definitely went down the

Speaker:

Elaine: rabbit hole for this one as

Speaker:

Elaine: well.

Speaker:

Elaine: And looked up "Ilê Aiyê," because obviously another set of

Speaker:

Elaine: words that I had never studied academically in Portuguese.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I thought it was fascinating

Speaker:

Elaine: that this is actually a Carnaval

Speaker:

Elaine: block.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so thinking about a neighborhood,

Speaker:

Elaine: effectively, in Salvador,

Speaker:

Elaine: which is one of the cities

Speaker:

Elaine: to the north, in Bahia, which

Speaker:

Elaine: is one of the states in Brazil.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: And this is especially

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting to me because a lot

Speaker:

Elaine: of the cultural influence from

Speaker:

Elaine: Brazil to the world is actually

Speaker:

Elaine: out of Rio de Janeiro, even to

Speaker:

Elaine: the point where people inside of

Speaker:

Elaine: Brazil say, oh, the official

Speaker:

Elaine: accent of Brazil is actually the

Speaker:

Elaine: carioca accent or the accent

Speaker:

Elaine: from Rio.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so to have something so influential coming from

Speaker:

Elaine: effectively a smaller city, maybe a little bit more, I don't

Speaker:

Elaine: want to say in the hinterlands, but definitely to the more quote

Speaker:

Elaine: unquote uncultured north, I thought was absolutely

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting to bring this in.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so Ilê Aiyê is this Carnaval block, and there is a group of

Speaker:

Elaine: people that would gather every year called the Bloco, which you

Speaker:

Elaine: can see inside of the title.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so this is a group of singers.

Speaker:

Elaine: They are generally Afro groups, Black or mulatto musicians.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so it's actually very

Speaker:

Elaine: exclusive from what I was

Speaker:

Elaine: reading.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so you can imagine that

Speaker:

Elaine: these parties actually go on

Speaker:

Elaine: from before Carnaval to after

Speaker:

Elaine: Carnaval.

Speaker:

Elaine: And one of the things I was

Speaker:

Elaine: reading is a part of that was

Speaker:

Elaine: that, specifically this

Speaker:

Elaine: particular bloco was responsible

Speaker:

Elaine: for a huge cultural revolution

Speaker:

Elaine: in Brazil.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I was reading that, I was

Speaker:

Elaine: like, oh, okay, this is really

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting because the title of

Speaker:

Elaine: the song is A Song of Afoxé, so

Speaker:

Elaine: like a song of afoxé in this

Speaker:

Elaine: style for and specifically like,

Speaker:

Elaine: hey, this is written for a bloco

Speaker:

Elaine: of Ilê.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so as they're saying, "Ilê Aiyê"

Speaker:

Elaine: multiple times, it really is

Speaker:

Elaine: paying tribute to this particular

Speaker:

Elaine: group that was so influential.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Elaine: as I was studying the impact of

Speaker:

Elaine: this particular bloco, it was really

Speaker:

Elaine: talking about the reclaiming

Speaker:

Elaine: of standards of beauty

Speaker:

Elaine: specifically for Black and

Speaker:

Elaine: mulatto, who were often held to

Speaker:

Elaine: maybe more Eurocentric standards.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Elaine: so this was almost like throwing off that standard of beauty

Speaker:

Elaine: and actually reclaiming their own sense of beauty in

Speaker:

Trist: MM.

Speaker:

Elaine: this dance and in this activity that they were participating in

Speaker:

Elaine: as a part of Carnaval.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so, I'm reading this and I'm

Speaker:

Elaine: quoting this directly from the

Speaker:

Elaine: Wikipedia article, where it said

Speaker:

Elaine: that "before the founding of Ilê Aiyê,

Speaker:

Elaine: Black men and women would never

Speaker:

Elaine: wear colorful dresses, would

Speaker:

Elaine: often not enter through the

Speaker:

Elaine: front door, would not wear Afro

Speaker:

Elaine: hairstyles, and black women would

Speaker:

Elaine: not use lipstick, all because

Speaker:

Elaine: of long standing racist stigmatization."

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm not quoting anymore. I

Speaker:

Elaine: think a lot of it had to do with

Speaker:

Elaine: colonialism, but also the impact

Speaker:

Elaine: of slavery in this area of

Speaker:

Elaine: Brazil. So

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that there is definitely

Speaker:

Elaine: this sense of cultural

Speaker:

Elaine: reclamation that Ilê Aiyê

Speaker:

Elaine: had brought to this region of

Speaker:

Elaine: Brazil, which is why I think it's

Speaker:

Elaine: actually amazing that there's

Speaker:

Elaine: a song for this group celebrating

Speaker:

Elaine: the bloco, celebrating

Speaker:

Elaine: the work that they've

Speaker:

Elaine: done. And

Speaker:

Elaine: as I take a look at the translation, it's "how beautiful you

Speaker:

Elaine: are to see. And

Speaker:

Elaine: the most beautiful beauty to have." It's

Speaker:

Elaine: the celebration of beauty that

Speaker:

Elaine: comes from being a part of this

Speaker:

Elaine: community. And

Speaker:

Elaine: then, the beauty transforms itself in you. And

Speaker:

Elaine: "Que maneira mais feliz de viver." So

Speaker:

Elaine: what is the happiest way to live? Just

Speaker:

Elaine: this exclamation of "Ah, this is amazing! What

Speaker:

Elaine: an amazing way to live life!" This is our community and this

Speaker:

Elaine: is where we can be free. And

Speaker:

Elaine: this is where we claim our standard of beauty and how it's not

Speaker:

Elaine: the same as what everyone else says it is. And

Speaker:

Elaine: so I can see how it's transformative and also what a celebration

Speaker:

Elaine: it is.

Speaker:

Trist: And you can hear the celebration of that in the sound of the

Speaker:

Trist: music and the singing.

Speaker:

Trist: Now as you speak of it and

Speaker:

Trist: translate it and talk about what

Speaker:

Trist: it's celebrating, you can hear

Speaker:

Trist: that in the music and in the

Speaker:

Trist: voices.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I wanted to wrap this up by talking a little bit about

Speaker:

Elaine: Candomblé, which is considered a Brazilian syncretic religion,

Speaker:

Elaine: and it's a synthesis between the West African gods and goddesses

Speaker:

Elaine: that came over with the West African slaves, that translated

Speaker:

Elaine: into a combination of that as well as whatever local religions

Speaker:

Elaine: they might have added in with the local brand of Christianity.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so you will see that with

Speaker:

Elaine: Haitian voodoo, you'll see that

Speaker:

Elaine: with Santeria, and in Brazil

Speaker:

Elaine: you'll see that in a system

Speaker:

Elaine: called Candomblé.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so a lot of these more African influenced songs also

Speaker:

Elaine: brought in elements of Candomblé into it as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: You could see that in the

Speaker:

Elaine: musical rhythm and in some of

Speaker:

Elaine: the other instruments that they

Speaker:

Elaine: have.

Speaker:

Elaine: So the atabaque, the agogô, and afoxé, which is actually that

Speaker:

Elaine: gourd with the beads on the outside that you twist.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: The cabaça is

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: is what they call it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so

Speaker:

Trist: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: as I think about all of that and

Speaker:

Elaine: how this particular song in some

Speaker:

Elaine: way represents all of that as

Speaker:

Elaine: well.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think it's an interesting

Speaker:

Elaine: window into Brazilian culture

Speaker:

Elaine: and specifically about the

Speaker:

Elaine: Afro-Brazilian culture.

Speaker:

Elaine: And in some ways you do hear

Speaker:

Elaine: some of that in samba as well,

Speaker:

Elaine: the rhythms that really borrow a

Speaker:

Elaine: lot from the West African

Speaker:

Elaine: culture,

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: but not so much, I think, in bossa nova.

Speaker:

Elaine: I don't know, I just

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: haven't analyzed so much.

Speaker:

Elaine: But we have talked in the past about the influence of African

Speaker:

Elaine: music in jazz, for instance, or in some of the call and response

Speaker:

Elaine: gospel music that we've covered here in the past.

Speaker:

Elaine: But, thinking about the African influence as it has come through

Speaker:

Elaine: Brazil with its slightly different perspective on all of

Speaker:

Elaine: these things, I think is an interesting view on life and

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting view on religion.

Speaker:

Elaine: Interesting view on how culture evolves in a particular region.

Speaker:

Trist: Indeed. Wow. Thanks.

Speaker:

Trist: I'm so glad that you were able to share all of that.

Speaker:

Elaine: And hopefully I did my Portuguese professor proud.

Speaker:

Elaine: Um,

Speaker:

Trist: I think

Speaker:

Elaine: yeah.

Speaker:

Trist: so.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, any other thoughts on this?

Speaker:

Trist: No, that's really it.

Speaker:

Trist: Well covered.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, we are going to shift gears and move into-

Speaker:

Trist: The mail bag.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's right. The Mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: And if you would like to get

Speaker:

Elaine: ahold of us, you can email us at

Speaker:

Elaine: themusiciansloupe@gmail.com,

Speaker:

Elaine: that's L O U P E. Or you can

Speaker:

Elaine: reach us on Instagram or Threads

Speaker:

Elaine: @themusiciansloupe.

Speaker:

Trist: That would be a great place if

Speaker:

Trist: you have any comments or any

Speaker:

Trist: stories or if you want to

Speaker:

Trist: correct any of my

Speaker:

Trist: pronunciations, since I spoke so

Speaker:

Trist: much Portuguese on this podcast

Speaker:

Trist: episode.

Speaker:

Trist: Or if you have your idea of some

Speaker:

Trist: of your favorite Brazilian

Speaker:

Trist: artists.

Speaker:

Trist: That'd be a great place you could share those with us.

Speaker:

Elaine: So this week's Mailbag is once again from Threads.

Speaker:

Elaine: It is from Bill Reppas from October of 2026.

Speaker:

Elaine: His account name is @reppasbill.

Speaker:

Elaine: "Non-musicians think being a

Speaker:

Elaine: gigging musician is a glamorized

Speaker:

Elaine: lifestyle.

Speaker:

Elaine: They don't see the four hour drive back home at 2am, drinking

Speaker:

Elaine: cheap gas station coffee, counting out twenty dollars in

Speaker:

Elaine: gas money, and dragging gear into your house at 4am before

Speaker:

Elaine: waking up for work.

Speaker:

Elaine: Fellow musicians, what is your

Speaker:

Elaine: ultimate late night gig survival

Speaker:

Elaine: story?"

Speaker:

Trist: That's kind of a generalization, like extreme version of what so

Speaker:

Trist: many people have had to do.

Speaker:

Trist: Different for depending on what instruments you play, obviously,

Speaker:

Trist: I always think about that.

Speaker:

Trist: I sometimes work as an audio engineer on events, party bands,

Speaker:

Trist: and things like that.

Speaker:

Trist: And so whenever you see the musicians show up, there is

Speaker:

Trist: always a part of me that's like, wow, I'm glad I'm primarily a

Speaker:

Trist: vocalist because on those kinds of gigs, it's like show right

Speaker:

Trist: up, a lot of times the microphone is provided, if not,

Speaker:

Trist: plug in your mic, maybe set up whatever your music, if you need

Speaker:

Trist: it for that event, your stand or something, you're ready to go.

Speaker:

Trist: Even if you play like saxophone

Speaker:

Trist: or a horn or something, you've

Speaker:

Trist: got something to get out and get

Speaker:

Trist: ready or your guitar, you got to

Speaker:

Trist: set up your amps and God forbid

Speaker:

Trist: you play the drums and you have

Speaker:

Trist: to drag in and set all of that

Speaker:

Trist: stuff up and take it all down,

Speaker:

Trist: and probably getting the same

Speaker:

Trist: bread as someone who just had to

Speaker:

Trist: walk up to the mic and sing and

Speaker:

Trist: leave.

Speaker:

Trist: So there's something nice about that.

Speaker:

Trist: That's at kind of a different level.

Speaker:

Trist: But yeah, you're doing your own band.

Speaker:

Trist: I think without talking exactly about what Bill there said, I

Speaker:

Trist: think every musician has some kind of version of that where

Speaker:

Trist: most people think a certain thing about what I do, and yet

Speaker:

Trist: there's all this other stuff that goes into it.

Speaker:

Trist: I think that's just kind of a

Speaker:

Trist: generic version of everyone's

Speaker:

Trist: got that.

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that there is something

Speaker:

Elaine: about this for me that really

Speaker:

Elaine: brings up what are the panic

Speaker:

Elaine: moments that you experience as a

Speaker:

Elaine: musician?

Speaker:

Elaine: And for me, definitely one of them is, oh, am I underprepared?

Speaker:

Elaine: And that is all on me.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like if I have too much on my plate at that point in time, or

Speaker:

Elaine: I get the music really late.

Speaker:

Elaine: That actually happened recently where I got the music too late

Speaker:

Elaine: for me to rehearse.

Speaker:

Elaine: I had set aside time to rehearse, and I didn't get the

Speaker:

Elaine: music until right before.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I was in rehearsal sight reading the music.

Speaker:

Elaine: Thankfully it was easy, but it was not something that I wanted

Speaker:

Elaine: to be doing.

Speaker:

Elaine: I liked to be prepared before I go into a gig, but that

Speaker:

Elaine: particular one also had a bunch of things go wrong because it

Speaker:

Elaine: was not on our regular site, like the entire sound system had

Speaker:

Elaine: to be laid down.

Speaker:

Elaine: And we got there, we basically

Speaker:

Elaine: waited for an hour, we didn't

Speaker:

Elaine: have our soundcheck for a long

Speaker:

Elaine: time.

Speaker:

Elaine: I didn't even have a mic for the first hour and a half before

Speaker:

Elaine: they were like, oh, you probably need a mic.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay.

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, the damper pedal on the keyboard I was playing was

Speaker:

Elaine: not the right match for it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so it was inversed.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I didn't have

Speaker:

Trist: Oh,

Speaker:

Elaine: a

Speaker:

Trist: right.

Speaker:

Elaine: damper.

Speaker:

Elaine: It was one of those things where I could have sustain, but in

Speaker:

Elaine: order to release a sustain, I hit the pedal which

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: is opposite to how I've trained.

Speaker:

Elaine: So all of these things went into

Speaker:

Elaine: it and I played the gig that

Speaker:

Elaine: way.

Speaker:

Elaine: But my entire job was to pretend that that was not an issue.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Trist: Right.

Speaker:

Elaine: so, I'm playing all the things I

Speaker:

Elaine: just had to like be very

Speaker:

Elaine: conscious about when I hit the

Speaker:

Elaine: pedal.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I think those are the types

Speaker:

Elaine: of minor panic stories that feed

Speaker:

Elaine: into the tapestry of a

Speaker:

Elaine: musician's life in that it isn't

Speaker:

Elaine: all "I show up and everything is

Speaker:

Elaine: perfect."

Speaker:

Elaine: I remember one Christmas I was

Speaker:

Elaine: playing and all of the power

Speaker:

Elaine: went out in the entire block as

Speaker:

Elaine: I was playing in the middle of a

Speaker:

Elaine: Christmas service.

Speaker:

Elaine: Funny enough, these are also the

Speaker:

Elaine: war stories that as I'm sitting

Speaker:

Elaine: around talking to other

Speaker:

Elaine: musicians, these are the things

Speaker:

Elaine: that people bring up of, uh, ha

Speaker:

Elaine: ha ha, I like you remember when

Speaker:

Elaine: this happened or like, oh, this

Speaker:

Elaine: happened

Speaker:

Trist: Always.

Speaker:

Elaine: to me while I was on tour or yeah, there's one thing happened

Speaker:

Elaine: to me over here and like, oh, wow, that's impressive.

Speaker:

Elaine: I feel like those are the types

Speaker:

Elaine: of stories that people tell each

Speaker:

Elaine: other to remind each other the

Speaker:

Elaine: privilege of playing music

Speaker:

Elaine: together.

Speaker:

Elaine: And to ground ourselves in the,

Speaker:

Elaine: oh, this is sometimes a grind

Speaker:

Elaine: because it's a job and work is

Speaker:

Elaine: sometimes hard.

Speaker:

Trist: That's true.

Speaker:

Trist: Might not have covered a lot

Speaker:

Trist: here, but I did indeed spend

Speaker:

Trist: time in the group, The Manhattan

Speaker:

Trist: Transfer.

Speaker:

Trist: And it was funny whenever we'd

Speaker:

Trist: have story time or be on the

Speaker:

Trist: road hearing stories from the

Speaker:

Trist: group, it was always stuff like

Speaker:

Trist: that.

Speaker:

Trist: It was always the crazy thing that happened.

Speaker:

Trist: The most memorable oddity from a

Speaker:

Trist: gig, more than some incredible

Speaker:

Trist: moment.

Speaker:

Trist: There's the occasional, oh, that

Speaker:

Trist: time we did that thing with

Speaker:

Trist: Dizzy Gillespie, but even then,

Speaker:

Trist: almost immediately away from the

Speaker:

Trist: great musical experience was

Speaker:

Trist: like, "Yeah.

Speaker:

Trist: And after the show, we went to

Speaker:

Trist: that one club and this happened

Speaker:

Trist: and this happened and this

Speaker:

Trist: happened.

Speaker:

Trist: Not down at this level that our

Speaker:

Trist: thread comes from where it's

Speaker:

Trist: just like your local gig that

Speaker:

Trist: you have that you break down

Speaker:

Trist: your own stuff, even at a higher

Speaker:

Trist: touring level.

Speaker:

Trist: There are the crazy stories of "Oh, we got booked in this place

Speaker:

Trist: at this time.

Speaker:

Trist: And then in that place really far away at a time that's not

Speaker:

Trist: far enough away.

Speaker:

Trist: So there's lots of those stories

Speaker:

Trist: too, about what you needed to do

Speaker:

Trist: to get to the next gig when

Speaker:

Trist: someone in an office booking it

Speaker:

Trist: on paper thought, oh, yep,

Speaker:

Trist: that's possible.

Speaker:

Trist: I opened up the map app and it showed that you could drive from

Speaker:

Trist: that place to that place in this amount of time.

Speaker:

Trist: So what's the problem?

Speaker:

Trist: You guys should be good."

Speaker:

Trist: They didn't have to be out there on the road doing it.

Speaker:

Trist: So, there are those stories too.

Speaker:

Trist: That tends to be the stuff that musicians remember the most are

Speaker:

Trist: those kind of oddities.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's interesting to think about in my current context, because

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm playing at a church and there are three services, first

Speaker:

Elaine: service is at 8. I think a lot of people in the services do not

Speaker:

Elaine: recognize that we have to be there so early until they talk

Speaker:

Elaine: to us and they're like, oh yeah, you know, like, what time did

Speaker:

Elaine: you get up?

Speaker:

Elaine: And I'm like, well, my alarm was set for 5.

Speaker:

Elaine: And they were like, what, 5?!

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm like, yeah, I've been here

Speaker:

Elaine: since 6:30, because that's when

Speaker:

Elaine: we're supposed to show up and

Speaker:

Elaine: set up.

Speaker:

Elaine: And downbeat is just before 7.

Speaker:

Elaine: Telling them that story often shows to them how unglamorous

Speaker:

Elaine: the life is, because they just see someone on stage and they're

Speaker:

Elaine: like, oh, wow, you're on stage and one person even was like,

Speaker:

Elaine: oh, you're famous.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm like, no, I just stand on a stage every week and you see me,

Speaker:

Elaine: so I look familiar.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm not famous.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I think that the other thing is that they don't recognize the

Speaker:

Elaine: sacrifice it takes to be able to do that week by week, whether

Speaker:

Elaine: it's the sacrifice of the sleep.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so the impact on my body or

Speaker:

Elaine: the sacrifice of not doing

Speaker:

Elaine: something on Saturday night so

Speaker:

Elaine: that I can go to bed early

Speaker:

Elaine: enough to get up early to play

Speaker:

Elaine: on Sunday, which I do gladly, I

Speaker:

Elaine: will say.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's not a sacrifice for me to do that.

Speaker:

Elaine: I will just give up my Saturday night, set boundaries, try to

Speaker:

Elaine: get as much sleep as I can.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I am not a morning person, so this is doubly hard for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: If someone were a morning bird,

Speaker:

Elaine: it's like, "Oh yeah, I get up at

Speaker:

Elaine: 4:30 every day!" I'm not that

Speaker:

Elaine: person.

Speaker:

Elaine: I am a person who is very happy sleeping in until 8 or 9.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I think about that and I

Speaker:

Elaine: think a lot of people see the

Speaker:

Elaine: musicians, they see the joy that

Speaker:

Elaine: we bring, which I think is our

Speaker:

Elaine: greatest gift.

Speaker:

Elaine: And at the same time, they don't see the work that goes into it.

Speaker:

Elaine: And

Speaker:

Trist: Right?

Speaker:

Elaine: I think that that's a part of the story that we can tell as

Speaker:

Elaine: musicians to help build that empathy and also to maybe take a

Speaker:

Elaine: little bit of the shine off of things, because I think that

Speaker:

Elaine: people fall too easily into a certain glorification into

Speaker:

Elaine: people who are on stage.

Speaker:

Trist: A common phrase you'll hear among touring working musicians.

Speaker:

Trist: Kind of a phrase along the lines

Speaker:

Trist: of, "Oh, we do the gigs for

Speaker:

Trist: free.

Speaker:

Trist: You pay me to get from one to the other" or, football.

Speaker:

Trist: Pro football players have been known to say that.

Speaker:

Trist: It's like, oh, I'll give you Sundays for free.

Speaker:

Trist: You just got to pay me from Monday through Saturday to get

Speaker:

Trist: my body ready to do that game of car crashes again.

Speaker:

Trist: Sunday's great.

Speaker:

Trist: It's just the in between is what I get paid for.

Speaker:

Trist: Or something like that, the joy of it.

Speaker:

Trist: I would do the game for free.

Speaker:

Trist: It's just all the preparation

Speaker:

Trist: that I want to make a lot of

Speaker:

Trist: money for.

Speaker:

Trist: Musicians like that too.

Speaker:

Trist: I know on the road all the time

Speaker:

Trist: we would say that, oh, you just

Speaker:

Trist: pay for the travel, but we would

Speaker:

Trist: do the gigs for free if we

Speaker:

Trist: could.

Speaker:

Elaine: Some of the people who I play

Speaker:

Elaine: with have been full time touring

Speaker:

Elaine: musicians in the past, and so

Speaker:

Elaine: occasionally we'll have these

Speaker:

Elaine: conversations about life on the

Speaker:

Elaine: road and those of us who haven't

Speaker:

Elaine: been on the road who are working

Speaker:

Elaine: day jobs and are musicians are

Speaker:

Elaine: listening along.

Speaker:

Elaine: And one of my friends, I just remember very distinctly saying,

Speaker:

Elaine: wow, you guys are not painting a good light on touring.

Speaker:

Elaine: And they they just looked at him

Speaker:

Elaine: and they were like, what makes

Speaker:

Elaine: you think that this is a good

Speaker:

Elaine: life?

Speaker:

Elaine: Um,

Speaker:

Trist: Right?

Speaker:

Elaine: but I mean, there's a lot of advantages.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think you and I have both

Speaker:

Elaine: talked about the joys of touring

Speaker:

Elaine: and the joys of traveling and

Speaker:

Elaine: the advantages that it gives

Speaker:

Elaine: you, and at the same time, how

Speaker:

Elaine: hard it can be on your body and

Speaker:

Elaine: how hard it can be just in

Speaker:

Elaine: general, if you're touring and

Speaker:

Elaine: it is a brutal travel schedule

Speaker:

Elaine: as opposed to maybe a more

Speaker:

Elaine: luxurious type of travel, or

Speaker:

Elaine: where you're staying in the same

Speaker:

Elaine: place for a couple of days or

Speaker:

Elaine: residency or something like

Speaker:

Elaine: that.

Speaker:

Trist: Indeed. Well, Bill, sorry I

Speaker:

Trist: didn't give you a ultimate late

Speaker:

Trist: night gig survival story, but

Speaker:

Trist: still a good thread to bring up

Speaker:

Trist: conversation about the less

Speaker:

Trist: glamorous parts of the music

Speaker:

Trist: life.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: Any last thoughts?

Speaker:

Trist: I think we got it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay. So with that, we're going to wrap up for the week.

Speaker:

Elaine: But before we leave you, we would love for you to share a

Speaker:

Elaine: playlist because we have two playlists to share with you.

Speaker:

Trist: One from each season.

Speaker:

Trist: So they make great playlists.

Speaker:

Trist: Even if you have friends that maybe, just don't listen to

Speaker:

Trist: podcasts or you're not sure if they might be interested in what

Speaker:

Trist: we do here.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe they'd be interested in the music so you can just share

Speaker:

Trist: any of the playlists that we've listed here in the show notes.

Speaker:

Trist: We've got them from lots of different platforms.

Speaker:

Trist: So, they make good road trip

Speaker:

Trist: playlists I found if you have a

Speaker:

Trist: long drive, because there's just

Speaker:

Trist: so much variety, we try to get

Speaker:

Trist: to lots of different kinds of

Speaker:

Trist: music.

Speaker:

Trist: And then, whoever you send it

Speaker:

Trist: to, if they find themselves

Speaker:

Trist: interested in one of the songs

Speaker:

Trist: and want to know more about it,

Speaker:

Trist: then maybe they can check out an

Speaker:

Trist: episode, but just know that

Speaker:

Trist: they're there for your own

Speaker:

Trist: edification.

Speaker:

Trist: But also, if you'd like to share one of those and you can help us

Speaker:

Trist: spread the word.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: Thank you very much and we will see you next week.

Speaker:

Trist: See you.

Speaker:

Elaine: You haven't heard of Jobim?

Speaker:

Elaine: and like gave me a CD.

Speaker:

Elaine: I still have that CD.

Speaker:

Trist: Hey, everybody, don't get old.

Speaker:

Elaine: she was like recalculating, recalculating.

Speaker:

Elaine: And like 20s later, I'm like, are you still thinking?

Speaker:

Elaine: the name, I'm like, oh, that's Brazilian.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then I was like, oh, I'm gonna get judged.

Listen for free

Show artwork for The Musician's Loupe

About the Podcast

The Musician's Loupe
Listen to music like a musician
A discussion about music and musicianship by Trist Curless (jazz singer, educator, sound engineer, and recording engineer, formerly of m-pact and The Manhattan Transfer) and Elaine Chao, M.Ed (multi-instrumentalist, vocalist, beatboxer, singer-songwriter, author, and former educator). Each week, we listen to a song together and discuss the music we love through the lens of decades in the music industry. Topics include analysis of songwriting, chord progression, instrumentation, recording technology, and arrangement.